Take the Cost Out of a Winner
Recover the original capital while retaining exposure to a successful holding.
- Difficulty
- Easy
- Time to result
- ~ongoing to results
- Steps
- 4
- Confidence
- 92%
This position-management rule addresses the tension between protecting gains and allowing exceptional companies to compound. When a holding has appreciated substantially, the investor can sell enough shares to recover the original invested capital and leave the remaining value exposed to further growth. The decision is not automatic: the company must still fit the top-down theme, its fundamentals and valuation must remain defensible, and its portfolio weight must be reviewed. Position size acts as an alert to reassess rather than a rigid trigger. By separating partial risk reduction from complete liquidation, the method avoids both indiscriminate profit-taking and passive acceptance of excessive concentration.
Origin
Extracted from Masters in Business, where Jay Bowen described a position-management practice used in long-term Bowen, Haynes portfolios.
Core principles
- 01Do not sell a quality holding merely because its price increased.
- 02Recovering original capital can reduce exposure without ending participation.
- 03Retain winners only while their fundamentals and thematic fit remain sound.
- 04Treat position size as a risk signal rather than an automatic sell command.
How to run it
- 1
Measure the embedded gain
Compare the position's current value with its original cost and calculate its portfolio weight.
Pro tip Review both absolute profit and concentration within the equity allocation.
Watch out A large percentage gain does not necessarily mean the position is large enough to threaten the portfolio.
- 2
Revalidate the investment
Confirm that the company still has sound fundamentals, an acceptable valuation, and a place in the portfolio's broader theme.
Pro tip Evaluate the company as if deciding whether to initiate a smaller position today.
Watch out Do not retain the remainder merely because it feels psychologically free.
- 3
Recover capital selectively
Sell enough shares to recover the original investment, or another deliberate amount, when risk reduction is warranted.
Pro tip Account for taxes, liquidity, and transaction costs before choosing the trim size.
Watch out A formulaic sale can be counterproductive if it creates avoidable costs or leaves the position poorly sized.
- 4
Let the remainder compound
Keep the residual holding while its long-term thesis and fundamentals remain intact.
Pro tip Set recurring reviews instead of an arbitrary price target.
Watch out The remaining position still represents real capital and can lose value.
In the wild
Bowen illustrated the rule with a hypothetical Visa holding bought for $10 million and later worth $40 million. The manager could sell $10 million, recovering the original cost, while allowing the remaining $30 million position to continue if its fundamentals and thematic fit remained attractive.
→ The portfolio realizes meaningful gains without fully abandoning a successful long-term holding.
Common mistakes
Selling solely because the stock doubled
Price appreciation alone does not show that the business or investment thesis has deteriorated.
Calling the remainder free money
Every retained share has current market value and must continue to earn its place in the portfolio.
Ignoring total portfolio weight
Recovering the original cost may still leave an unacceptably concentrated residual position.
Is it for you?
Best for
It is best for long-term investors holding substantially appreciated, fundamentally strong companies.
Not ideal for
It is not ideal for deteriorating businesses, tax-insensitive short-term trades, or positions that remain dangerously concentrated after trimming.
From the transcript
“take the cost out of the stock.”
“I love taking the profits and taking the cost out”
“We never just sell it just because it's doubled, tripled”
From the episode
Jay Bowen Discusses Pension Fund Management
Jay Bowen