MMasters in Business
← All episodes
Tina Vandersteel21 January 2022

Tina Vandersteel on Emerging-Country Debt (Podcast)

4Frameworks
15Insights

Listen

Frameworks in this episode

Insights & moments

The myth-busts, hot takes, explainers, and tools worth keeping.

Myth Buster· 1

Myth Buster28:06

Why Textbook Currency-Parity Models Broke Down

Vandersteel says traditional finance and macroeconomic textbooks became less useful when currencies stopped behaving according to uncovered interest-rate parity. Large cross-currency bases and expanding central-bank swap and repo lines changed the mechanisms practitioners had learned.

  • Interest-rate differentials once provided a standard way to price developed-market currency forwards.
  • Large cross-currency bases violated the simplified textbook relationship.
  • Central-bank swap lines and repo lines became important constraints on those bases.
  • Practitioners must account for evolving market plumbing rather than rely blindly on old models.

“the finance textbooks are also wrong.”

Tina Vandersteel · 29:36

“finance and macroeconomic textbooks are actually not all that useful these days because what you would have learned hardly applies anymore.”

Tina Vandersteel · 30:37
#currencies#interest rate parity#central banks#market structure

Hot Take· 2

Hot Take06:39

Why Emerging-Market Locals Can Be the Biggest Pessimists

Living in Brazil taught Vandersteel that local sentiment can be more pessimistic than foreign sentiment because citizens consume a steady flow of negative news. She argues that readers are rarely trained to examine media incentives and biases systematically.

  • Brazil's vibrant press repeatedly emphasized worst-case interpretations.
  • The journalistic incentive that "if it bleeds, it leads" can skew perceived reality.
  • Internet distribution can intensify the same bias.
  • Investors should examine sources, motivations and selection effects.

“the locals are the most pessimistic.”

Tina Vandersteel · 06:51

“Schools don't really teach us anything about information hygiene or how to evaluate what you see”

Tina Vandersteel · 08:21
#media#information hygiene#brazil#sentiment
Hot Take40:00

Distressed Emerging Countries Offered Insurable Upside

Vandersteel identifies unusually wide spreads between high-yield and investment-grade emerging sovereigns. The opportunity lies in countries where investors can hold bonds for the no-default upside while separately protecting the default case.

  • High-yield emerging spreads were historically wide outside the pandemic extreme.
  • Bond prices in some countries implied high default probabilities.
  • The most attractive cases allowed investors to insure the downside.
  • Ivory Coast, Ghana and El Salvador were cited as examples.

“can you ensure the default case while holding on for the no default case?”

Tina Vandersteel · 40:46

“I would say Ivory Coast is one, Ghana is one, um El Salvador is one.”

Tina Vandersteel · 41:06
#distressed debt#default#ghana#el salvador

Explainer· 5

Explainer03:40

How Hyperinflation Made Brazil's Financial System Faster

Vandersteel explains that Brazil's history of high inflation forced its financial infrastructure and practitioners to become unusually sophisticated. Daily interest compounding and next-day check clearing reflected the high cost of allowing money to sit idle.

  • Brazil's Plano Real ended hyperinflation and introduced the currency still used today.
  • Checks cleared faster because inflation made delays costly.
  • Brazil used daily compounded interest rather than the simple-interest conventions common in the US.
  • Operating through instability trained highly capable financial professionals.

“if I wrote a check in Salpolo, it cleared the next day, where back in the US it would be several days”

Tina Vandersteel · 06:03

“in Brazil they use daily compounded interest because their history is that inflation is very high”

Tina Vandersteel · 06:26
#brazil#hyperinflation#financial systems
Explainer12:59

An Emerging Country Is Not Necessarily an Emerging Market

The episode distinguishes a country's credit classification from the accessibility of the market where its bonds trade. A lower- or middle-income issuer may be an emerging country while a dollar bond clearing through Euroclear behaves operationally like a developed market instrument.

  • Emerging countries are commonly lower- or middle-income countries or past defaulters.
  • Emerging-market status concerns foreign access, taxation and market infrastructure.
  • A Ghanaian dollar bond can be an emerging-country bond traded through developed-market rails.
  • Local-currency and external bonds from one issuer can belong to different market-access categories.

“we distinguish between emerging countries and emerging markets.”

Tina Vandersteel · 13:20

“Emerging market has much more to do with the accessibility by foreigners into a market”

Tina Vandersteel · 13:51
#taxonomy#emerging markets#market access#bonds
Explainer14:49

Why an Emerging-Market Corporate Is a Compound Risk

Vandersteel argues that corporate analysis cannot be separated from sovereign power in emerging countries. Even when a bond is governed by US or UK law, the operating assets remain subject to the law and political authority of the country where they are located.

  • The sovereign is a powerful agent over domestic companies and assets.
  • Corporate credit combines company-specific and sovereign risks.
  • Foreign-law documentation does not move physical assets outside local jurisdiction.
  • Rule of law and transparency affect the compound exposure.

“the corporates are really a compound risk with respect to their sovereign”

Tina Vandersteel · 14:59

“The assets are still in Ghana, so we think of them as a compound risk.”

Tina Vandersteel · 15:25
#corporate debt#sovereign risk#legal risk
Explainer26:08

The Multi-Trillion-Dollar Scale of Emerging-Market Debt

Vandersteel sizes the index-eligible market at roughly $1.4 trillion each for dollar sovereign and corporate debt and $2.5 trillion for local-currency debt. She suggests doubling that total to approximate the wider investable universe and notes that negative developed-market yields helped increase demand.

  • Dollar sovereign and quasi-sovereign index debt was about $1.4 trillion.
  • The corporate emerging-market index was also about $1.4 trillion.
  • Local-currency emerging debt was about $2.5 trillion.
  • The broader investable universe may be approximately twice the index-eligible total.
  • Negative-yielding developed-market debt encouraged investors to seek positive yields.

“for local currency e M debt it's around two and a half trillion.”

Tina Vandersteel · 26:41

“I think you could safely multiply that by another to capture all possible investible debt.”

Tina Vandersteel · 26:50
#market size#emerging debt#fixed income
Explainer49:10

Inflation Lets Governments Default Without Saying So

Vandersteel frames inflation and negative real rates as a gradual form of default. Financial repression allows nominal debts to be paid while their real value erodes, reducing debt burdens without an explicit political decision to refuse payment.

  • Inflation transfers value from creditors to debtors.
  • Negative real rates erode the purchasing power of bonds, cash and deposits.
  • Governments can reduce debt-to-GDP ratios while continuing nominal payments.
  • The losses fall on savers whose nominal assets are someone else's liabilities.
  • Capital controls make it harder for citizens to escape repression.

“inflation is a form of default where you don't have to declare it.”

Tina Vandersteel · 49:40

“You don't fail to pay, you just fail to pay in real terms.”

Tina Vandersteel · 52:32
#inflation#financial repression#real returns#sovereign debt

Story· 4

Story11:48

Venezuela's Unprecedented Four-Year Repayment Choice

Vandersteel describes Venezuela as an example of the limits of sovereign forecasting. After running out of money, the country continued directing oil revenue to foreign creditors for four years while its population suffered, a choice she says investors could not reasonably have predicted.

  • Sovereign defaults often develop gradually before arriving suddenly.
  • Venezuela continued servicing foreign creditors after exhausting its money.
  • Oil production allowed repayment to continue despite severe domestic deprivation.
  • Extreme political decisions can defeat confident country forecasts.

“Venezuela ran out of money in and continued to pull oil out of the ground and starve its population to pay foreign creditors for four…”

Tina Vandersteel · 12:31

“I don't think anyone would have predicted anyone would do something so insane.”

Tina Vandersteel · 12:50
#venezuela#sovereign default#political risk
Story24:41

The Simple Leverage Choice That Separated GMO from LTCM

As a young strategist, Vandersteel prepared versions of the same relative-value trades for GMO and Long-Term Capital Management. GMO's conservative leverage reflected concern about default risk, while LTCM's heavy leverage focused on hedging ordinary market risk; the difference proved fatal for one and survivable for the other.

  • The same trade can have radically different outcomes under different leverage.
  • Market-risk hedging does not eliminate default or tail risk.
  • Conservative leverage preserves the ability to survive temporary divergence.
  • The comparison helped attract Vandersteel to GMO.

“that simple choice turned out to be fatal for one and not the other.”

Tina Vandersteel · 25:21

“these guys are smarter than those Nobel laureates.”

Tina Vandersteel · 25:33
#ltcm#leverage#tail risk#gmo
Story35:17

How Weekend Bankruptcy Rewrites Reveal Sovereign Risk

Kazakhstan and Azerbaijan provide examples of governments rewriting bankruptcy laws over a weekend to impose losses on bank creditors. Vandersteel says analysts must file such events away as precedent and judge whether current rulers are likely to repeat them.

  • Governments can rapidly alter legal rules governing creditor recoveries.
  • Kazakhstan imposed severe losses on bank creditors.
  • Azerbaijan followed a similar playbook but obtained little debt relief despite reputational damage.
  • Past conduct informs, but cannot determine, future political behavior.

“over the course of a weekend they rewrote their bankruptcy laws and basically wiped out the bank creditors.”

Tina Vandersteel · 35:53

“all you can do is file these away and understand what's happened in the past”

Tina Vandersteel · 37:24
#bankruptcy#rule of law#kazakhstan#azerbaijan
Story56:19

Burnout Sent Vandersteel from Wall Street to Olympic Trials

After an exhausting run through the Asian and Russian financial crises, Vandersteel took up rowing and eventually left JP Morgan to pursue the US Olympic team. She missed the team but built a life in Boston, met her husband and ultimately joined GMO.

  • A client suggested sport because Vandersteel worked constantly.
  • Rowing exposed how her enthusiasm for JP Morgan had faded.
  • Her coach encouraged her to quit and train for Athens.
  • She finished second at the 2003 trials before missing the Olympic team.
  • The move to Boston indirectly led to her career at GMO.

“I just burned out a lot.”

Tina Vandersteel · 57:05

“you're so talented. Why don't you quit your job then and try and train for Athens?”

Vandersteel's rowing coach, quoted by Tina Vandersteel · 58:26
#rowing#burnout#career change#olympics

Takeaway· 3

Takeaway09:04

Trust Market Prices More Than Real-Time Commentary

Vandersteel invokes the phenomenon commonly called Gell-Mann amnesia: readers spot obvious errors in coverage of their own fields but trust the next article on an unfamiliar subject. For investment decisions, she prefers the information embedded in prices over rapidly produced interpretations and market color.

  • Expertise exposes how frequently news reports get technical subjects wrong.
  • Readers often fail to carry that skepticism into unfamiliar topics.
  • Real-time events are especially difficult to interpret accurately.
  • Market prices aggregate information without requiring a persuasive narrative.

“the next article is about something you don't really know anything about, and you just trust the source.”

Tina Vandersteel · 09:52

“You just have to witness the price.”

Tina Vandersteel · 10:33
#media literacy#market prices#investment research
Takeaway38:14

Some Emerging Bonds Can Supply Positive-Yield Portfolio Ballast

Developed-market government bonds can act as crisis ballast but may charge investors through negative yields. Vandersteel says a small group of emerging local markets, particularly Taiwan and Korea, can offer similar defensive statistical properties while retaining positive yields.

  • Defensive government debt acts like insurance during risk-asset declines.
  • Negative yields represent an insurance premium paid by the holder.
  • Some currency-hedged or selectively unhedged emerging bonds may preserve defensive properties.
  • Taiwan and Korea are cited as relatively safe examples.
  • No bond market is entirely safe from financial repression.

“is holding a negative yielding asset right it's an insurance premium almost.”

Tina Vandersteel · 38:50

“They are the Taiwans and Koreas of the world.”

Tina Vandersteel · 39:33
#defensive assets#taiwan#korea#positive yield
Takeaway1:08:03

Try, Fail and Learn Before Collecting More Credentials

Vandersteel advises new entrants to use a large bank's training program to experience multiple roles and discover their fit. Her own decision not to pursue a PhD reinforced the lesson that practitioners often learn more by trying real work, making mistakes and adjusting.

  • Rotational training reveals preferences that are difficult to predict in advance.
  • Cultural fit materially affects career satisfaction.
  • Failure and experimentation create practical knowledge.
  • Credentials should be tied to a concrete use case.
  • A degree may add little when someone is already practicing the relevant craft.

“I think it's very hard to imagine what you're going to like without actually doing it right.”

Tina Vandersteel · 1:08:23

“I think you've got to try stuff, fail, try again.”

Tina Vandersteel · 1:09:17
#career advice#experimentation#cultural fit#education