Why “Smart Beta” Is More Marketing Than Investment Description
French prefers “alternatively weighted” because smart beta is not inherently intelligent. The substantive distinction is how an index departs from market-cap weighting to alter concentration and the portfolio's risk-return profile.
- Market-cap weighting can concentrate exposure
- Alternative weighting changes the risk-return profile
- The word “smart” does not explain the methodology
- Product labels should describe the construction mechanism
“I am on that side of the film.”
“I like alternatively weighted right”