MMasters in Business
← All episodes
Sharon French07 June 2019

Sharon French Discusses Smart Beta ETFs

2Frameworks
14Insights

Listen

Frameworks in this episode

Insights & moments

The myth-busts, hot takes, explainers, and tools worth keeping.

Myth Buster· 1

Myth Buster12:36

Why “Smart Beta” Is More Marketing Than Investment Description

French prefers “alternatively weighted” because smart beta is not inherently intelligent. The substantive distinction is how an index departs from market-cap weighting to alter concentration and the portfolio's risk-return profile.

  • Market-cap weighting can concentrate exposure
  • Alternative weighting changes the risk-return profile
  • The word “smart” does not explain the methodology
  • Product labels should describe the construction mechanism

“I am on that side of the film.”

Sharon French · 13:09

“I like alternatively weighted right”

Sharon French · 13:23
#smart beta#indexing#etfs

Explainer· 4

Explainer20:13

How Women in ETFs Builds an Industry Talent Network

Women in ETFs was created to connect a large but dispersed population of women working across ETF product, trading, legal, distribution, and leadership roles. Its global network uses mentoring, sponsorship, events, and public advocacy to strengthen career pathways and promote diversity of thought.

  • The organization operates globally through local chapters
  • Its mission is to connect, support, and inspire
  • Senior executives mentor and sponsor newer professionals
  • Men are encouraged to participate in advancing equality

“So our mission is to connect, support and inspire UM.”

Sharon French · 22:11

“it's really having some of the more senior executives within ETFs mentor and sponsor and connect the women who are joining us who are just…”

Sharon French · 22:19
#women in finance#etfs#mentorship#diversity
Explainer38:34

What Direct Indexing Adds Beyond Owning an Index Fund

Direct indexing replaces a pooled index vehicle with direct ownership of its underlying securities. French highlights tax harvesting, customization, and potentially lower index-provider costs as its central advantages.

  • Direct ownership enables tax-loss harvesting
  • Investors can customize holdings and exclusions
  • Index-provider fees may be avoided
  • Self-indexing and direct indexing are reshaping the index industry

“That creates a great opportunity for tax efficiency, tax harvesting, customization.”

Sharon French · 38:42

“the world of indexation as it existed ten years ago is also changing because of self indexing and direct indexation.”

Sharon French · 39:31
#direct indexing#tax harvesting#customization#indexing
Explainer52:24

How the Financial Crisis Accelerated the Shift to Passive Investing

French says the 2008 crisis damaged trust in financial institutions and changed ETFs from experimental holdings into major portfolio components. Investors interpreted index exposure as a way to reduce dependence on managers and mitigate risks they no longer trusted institutions to control.

  • Institutional failures damaged investor trust
  • Bailouts intensified public skepticism
  • ETF use moved from experimentation to core allocation
  • Passive exposure was perceived as risk mitigation

“They didn't trust the institutions that were running their money in a lot of cases, especially the ones that got bailed out”

Sharon French · 52:37

“I think they made it a prominent part of their portfolio construction”

Sharon French · 52:57
#financial crisis#passive investing#trust#etfs
Explainer58:02

Why Three Firms Came to Dominate the ETF Industry

French attributes ETF concentration primarily to first-mover advantage and scale. Vanguard, BlackRock, and State Street captured early adopters, accumulated assets in passive products, and built cost advantages that later entrants could not reproduce quickly.

  • Early entry captured the first wave of ETF adopters
  • Passive products accumulated scale over many years
  • Later firms shifted toward differentiated or active products
  • Scale prevents smaller competitors from matching market share quickly

“they just had a giant head start and everybody else's playing catch up.”

Sharon French · 58:24

“nobody has the scale or can buy or build the scare in a short period of time”

Sharon French · 59:27
#etf industry#scale#first-mover advantage#competition

Story· 3

Story08:15

Inside BlackRock's Special-Forces Culture During the ETF Boom

French describes the early iShares environment as an intense professional boot camp. Lofty expectations and constant competitive pressure made the culture difficult, but they also sharpened employees' skills and made alumni highly employable.

  • Employees faced unusually high expectations
  • Daily competitive pressure accelerated skill development
  • The culture was difficult but professionally formative
  • iShares alumni became attractive hires across the industry

“It's like going to boot camp for the Special Forces.”

Sharon French · 08:15

“every single day you are walking into battle, the bar is set so high for everything that you have to achieve”

Sharon French · 08:50
#blackrock#ishares#career development#culture
Story59:46

How a Disputed Track Record Destroyed F-Squared's Trust

French recounts how an SEC investigation into the provenance of F-Squared's pre-2008 track record led to a fine, leadership removal, client withdrawals, and the eventual sale of remaining assets. Although most employees were uninvolved and later found new roles, the firm's client trust proved unrecoverable.

  • The SEC challenged the historical record marketed before 2008
  • The post-2008 live record was not the disputed period
  • Regulatory action triggered client withdrawals
  • The remaining assets were sold through an asset purchase agreement
  • Employees below the CEO were generally able to continue their careers

“I think what happened is the trust was just eroded, but from the clients.”

Sharon French · 1:03:16

“managing through crisis and trying to you know, keep everybody on the boat until such time that you've got to get everybody safely off the…”

Sharon French · 1:03:40
#f-squared#sec#track record#trust#crisis
Story1:15:16

The Business Win Sharon French Calls Her Stupidest Decision

While eight months pregnant, French forged a doctor's note and flew across the Pacific for a finalist presentation because relationship continuity mattered to the Japanese client. Her company won, but she went into premature labor two weeks later and now uses the story to warn mentees against sacrificing health and family for work.

  • The client relationship depended on continuity
  • French ignored medical and family warnings
  • The company won the business
  • She went into premature labor after returning
  • She now teaches others to prioritize health and family

“What was I thinking our number one priorities, ourselves, our healths in our family.”

Sharon French · 1:17:23

“That was the stupidest thing I ever did. I put my life at risk and my unborn child's life at risk.”

Sharon French · 1:17:27
#work-life balance#pregnancy#career mistakes#priorities

Tool· 1

Tool24:56

A Speaker Bureau That Removes the “We Couldn't Find Women” Excuse

Women in ETFs assembled a vetted bureau of experienced, media-trained female experts. By supplying topic-specific candidates directly to journalists and conference organizers, the group converts a representation problem into a practical sourcing solution.

  • Applicants must demonstrate topic expertise
  • Speakers must be media trained
  • The list is distributed to media and event organizers
  • Each request can receive several qualified candidates

“we're sort of spoon feeding the media who are are are having a hard time finding female speakers.”

Sharon French · 25:21

“sometimes you just need to take action. That's what we did.”

Sharon French · 26:52
#speakers#media#diversity#representation

Takeaway· 5

Takeaway05:00

Why Active and Passive Investing Belong in the Same Portfolio

French argues that active and passive management are complementary rather than mutually exclusive. Investors can reserve fees and risk budgets for genuine alpha while using efficient beta for broad, inexpensive exposure.

  • Use efficient beta for core market exposure
  • Allocate active risk where managers can plausibly add value
  • Evaluate the portfolio as a combined system
  • Avoid treating active and passive investing as rival ideologies

“the real prudent way to run the pension fund, as an example, is to figure out how to combine intelligent alpha with efficient beta so…”

Sharon French · 05:00

“they're not mutually exclusive, they're complementary.”

Barry Ritholtz · 06:30
#active investing#passive investing#portfolio construction
Takeaway54:06

Why the Chief Risk Officer Now Belongs Beside the CEO

After the financial crisis, firms elevated risk leadership and made risk processes central to institutional due diligence. French views direct CEO access for the chief risk officer as consistent with an asset manager's fiduciary responsibility and necessary for rebuilding client trust.

  • Chief risk officers increasingly report to CEOs
  • Institutional requests scrutinize risk processes
  • Risk governance supports fiduciary accountability
  • Strong controls can restore trust without eliminating prudent freedom

“the chief risk officer reports to the CEO. And that wasn't a position that necessarily exists.”

Sharon French · 54:27

“we are stewards of our clients capitals, we are fiduciaries. We need to take that particular function seriously.”

Sharon French · 54:42
#risk management#governance#fiduciary duty#financial institutions
Takeaway1:08:17

Why Careers Need Both Tough Mentors and Active Sponsors

French credits a demanding early boss with teaching her to diagnose core problems and persist through difficulty. She distinguishes that developmental pressure from later mentorship that taught stakeholder alignment, and she now pays both forms of support forward to younger women.

  • Tough feedback can improve capability without coddling
  • Giving people runway builds independent problem-solving skill
  • Stakeholder alignment is a separate leadership capability
  • Sponsorship opens opportunities beyond advice
  • Senior professionals should develop the next generation

“I didn't need coddling. I needed to understand how to be better and do better”

Sharon French · 1:09:14

“I'm a big believer in mentors. I'm a big believer in sponsorship.”

Sharon French · 1:10:20
#mentorship#sponsorship#leadership#careers
Takeaway1:18:41

French's Career Advice: Work Where Finance Meets Technology

French recommends that younger professionals study the intersection of financial services, data, and technology. ETFs, digital advice, and data-driven portfolio construction are changing both the products investors use and the skills finance careers require.

  • Millennials are growing up with ETFs and digital advice
  • Portfolio construction increasingly depends on data literacy
  • Technology is reshaping asset management delivery
  • The finance-technology intersection offers strong career opportunities

“I am big into how the financial world meets the technology world.”

Sharon French · 1:19:06

“I love the intersection of finance and technology”

Sharon French · 1:19:16
#fintech#careers#data#asset management
Takeaway1:19:26

The Investing Lesson French Wishes She Learned Earlier

After experiencing major market corrections and industry scandals, French says she became more pragmatic about risk. Her retrospective lesson is that optimism about perpetual growth must be balanced by explicit risk management before adversity arrives.

  • Early-career idealism understated downside risk
  • Repeated market corrections produced practical humility
  • Risk understanding should precede portfolio stress
  • Experience shifted French from idealism toward pragmatism

“I wish I understood risk a little bit more.”

Sharon French · 1:19:30

“I'm much more practical now, much more pragmatic”

Sharon French · 1:19:52
#risk#market crashes#investing lessons#pragmatism