A Three-Basis-Point Index Fund Is Not Economically Free
Green agrees that Vanguard's pressure on fees benefited investors but argues that near-zero expense ratios do not mean the business operates without revenue. Securities lending and enormous scale help subsidize extremely low headline fees.
- Early Vanguard fees were cheap relative to active funds but much higher than today
- Scale spreads operating costs across trillions of dollars
- Funds can earn revenue by lending securities to short sellers
- Headline expense ratios do not capture every economic subsidy
“it just doesn't mean it's free, it's factally free. It's effectively free.”
“securities lending is actually what's paying for Vanguard”