MMasters in Business
← All episodes
20 October 2017

Jim Ross Recounts the Rise of the SPYs

3Frameworks
13Insights

Listen

Frameworks in this episode

Insights & moments

The myth-busts, hot takes, explainers, and tools worth keeping.

Myth Buster· 2

Myth Buster28:39

Owning Several Funds Does Not Guarantee Diversification

A portfolio can appear diversified while multiple funds hold substantially the same companies. Ross recommends examining the combined underlying exposures, particularly when mixing broad indexes with active large-cap and mid-cap products.

  • Fund labels can conceal overlapping holdings
  • Large-cap, mid-cap, and broad-market funds may duplicate exposures
  • The whole portfolio matters more than the number of products
  • A portfolio analyzer can reveal the true exposure map

“you really have to lens through and make sure you understand what”

Jim Ross · 28:48

“Do you think they're diversified,”

Barry Ritholtz · 29:17
#diversification#portfolio overlap#asset allocation#risk
Myth Buster36:16

Political Instability and Market Volatility Are Not the Same Thing

Ross argues that alarming political news does not automatically determine equity prices. Markets can remain anchored to company fundamentals and long-term expectations, although investors should still build portfolios capable of surviving genuine shocks.

  • Political instability may not translate directly into market declines
  • Underlying company fundamentals remain important
  • Unexpected shocks should be considered in advance
  • Diversification and rebalancing support long-term resilience

“instability in some cases does not necessarily”

Jim Ross · 37:01

“drive the market.”

Jim Ross · 37:05
#volatility#politics#market risk#diversification

Hot Take· 2

Hot Take24:56

A Memorable Ticker Can Help an ETF Win Attention

ETF ticker symbols function as unusually important branding assets because investors and traders use them constantly. Ross cites research suggesting word-like tickers perform better than random letters, while cautioning that a clever symbol should never replace product understanding.

  • ETF product design includes naming, marketing, and ticker selection
  • Word-like tickers are easier to remember
  • Sector SPDR symbols became shorthand among traders
  • Fortuitous news can amplify a relevant ticker

“Take a symbols matter,”

Jim Ross · 26:22

“it can help get your attention,”

Jim Ross · 27:03
#branding#ticker symbols#etf marketing#behavioral finance
Hot Take47:17

Asset Managers Should Expect Technology Firms to Attack Their Margins

Ross expects technology to keep changing how investors buy portfolios and obtain advice. Younger investors may prefer direct digital access while still seeking guidance at selected moments, creating opportunities for new entrants to take profitable pieces of traditional financial services.

  • Managed portfolios are increasingly purchased through technology
  • Younger investors often prefer direct access
  • Digital delivery does not eliminate demand for advice
  • High financial-industry margins attract technological competition

“there could be more tech disruption in the financial space.”

Jim Ross · 47:53

“Your margin is”

Barry Ritholtz · 48:12
#fintech#asset management#robo advice#disruption

Explainer· 5

Explainer09:00

Why SPY Became More Than a Buy-and-Hold Index Fund

Ross attributes SPY's dominance to first-mover advantage and the trading volume that accumulated around it. Its tight spread and enormous turnover made it a liquidity instrument used for trading, hedging, and as an alternative to futures, not merely a long-term index holding.

  • SPY had a seven-year first-mover lead
  • Established volume reinforced later liquidity
  • Its bid-ask spread remained exceptionally tight
  • Market participants use it for both brief trades and long holdings

“This is a liquidity product.”

Jim Ross · 10:32

“It's used for as an alternative to Fugere's a lot of different uses to it, very flexible,”

Jim Ross · 10:34
#spy#liquidity#trading#index funds
Explainer11:55

Why Billion-Dollar SPY Flows Do Not Require Matching Stock Trades

ETF shares can expand or contract through in-kind transfers of the underlying securities. As a result, portfolio managers generally do not trade every stock merely because the fund receives or loses billions of dollars; their more direct work centers on index changes and corporate actions.

  • Daily fund flows can move by billions of dollars
  • Underlying securities arrive or leave in kind
  • Portfolio managers focus more heavily on index changes
  • Authorized market activity differs from ordinary mutual-fund cash flows

“It comes to us in kind”

Jim Ross · 12:08

“we deliver it out in kind.”

Jim Ross · 12:10
#etf mechanics#in-kind creation#portfolio management#spy
Explainer17:10

How GLD Turned Physical Gold Into an Accessible Holding

GLD gave retail investors and financial advisers a liquid way to obtain direct gold exposure without buying and storing coins. Ross explains that the fund is backed by physical bullion, with only a small cash balance related to expenses.

  • Traditional retail gold access carried meaningful friction and cost
  • GLD offered exposure to gold itself rather than mining-company execution risk
  • Physical gold bars back the fund
  • The World Gold Council partnered with State Street for marketing and distribution

“democratizing the ability to invest in gold.”

Jim Ross · 17:25

“g l D physical gold with”

Jim Ross · 18:19
#gold#gld#commodities#democratization
Explainer30:15

Why ESG Product Ideas Fail Without Reliable Underlying Data

State Street's gender-diversity ETF originated in research conducted with CalSTRS and looked beyond board seats into executive management. Ross stresses that an appealing theme cannot support an investable, repeatable index unless the relevant company data can be obtained and updated.

  • CalSTRS approached State Street for research
  • Board membership alone offered an incomplete diversity measure
  • The team examined diversity deeper in executive management
  • An index needs consistent data that can be refreshed

“if you can't get”

Jim Ross · 31:05

“to the core data, it's hard to build a product”

Jim Ross · 31:08
#esg#gender diversity#index design#data quality
Explainer31:48

When Passive Funds Cannot Sell, Stewardship Becomes the Lever

An active manager can exit a company when long-term risks become unacceptable, but an index provider generally must continue holding index constituents. State Street therefore engages management and uses proxy voting to influence governance, diversity, social, and environmental practices over a longer horizon.

  • Index mandates constrain the ability to sell individual companies
  • Passive ownership increases the importance of engagement
  • State Street approaches companies with long-term concerns
  • Proxy voting supplies leverage when divestment is unavailable

“We as an index provider,”

Jim Ross · 32:22

“the the stick there is that we”

Jim Ross · 33:31
#passive investing#governance#proxy voting#stewardship

Story· 3

Story02:27

How Asking for More Work Put Jim Ross on the SPY Team

Ross entered State Street through a new fund-administration unit after leaving public accounting. With more capacity than assigned work, he volunteered to help and was brought into the SPY project to prepare its first financial statements.

  • Ross originally planned to remain at State Street for only two or three years
  • His accounting background matched an immediate pre-launch need
  • He joined after others had already worked on the ETF for years
  • He credits persistence and chance rather than claiming sole authorship

“My smartest move was staying involved in that”

Jim Ross · 05:53

“I deserve very little of it.”

Jim Ross · 05:36
#spy#career#state street#etf history
Story07:13

SPY Emerged From the Search for a Better Post-Crash Instrument

The American Stock Exchange approached State Street with the idea that became SPY. The concept followed the 1987 crash and combined a transparent basket of S&P 500 stocks with exchange trading and novel in-kind securities transfers.

  • The American Stock Exchange originated the proposal
  • The ETF label was not yet established
  • The fund disclosed its underlying holdings daily
  • Moving hundreds of securities in kind every day was novel

“The American Stock Exchange came to us with this idea.”

Jim Ross · 07:13

“the name ETF was not known.”

Jim Ross · 07:23
#spy#market crash#innovation#amex
Story52:51

SPY Was Designed for Institutions, Not the Retail Revolution It Created

The original ETF was designed primarily for institutional trading firms. Ross says the later adoption by financial advisers and retail investors was not part of the plan, illustrating how a product's largest market can emerge only after launch.

  • Institutional trading was the original design target
  • Retail and adviser adoption was largely unanticipated
  • The unexpected audience would have changed strategic planning
  • Product teams cannot know every future use in advance

“We developed the”

Jim Ross · 53:12

“The adoption of them from”

Jim Ross · 53:20
#etf history#product strategy#retail investing#market adoption

Takeaway· 1

Takeaway14:39

Fee Compression Hurts Providers but Expands Investor Access

Ross acknowledges that declining fees pressure the ETF business while emphasizing the benefit to investors. The total cost improvement extends beyond expense ratios to narrower bid-ask spreads and dramatically lower brokerage commissions.

  • Fee compression affects the global ETF industry
  • Providers sometimes adjust prices to remain competitive
  • Lower expense ratios are only one component of falling costs
  • Tighter spreads and lower commissions broaden access

“It's good for investors.”

Jim Ross · 15:23

“the commission rates have welcome down.”

Jim Ross · 15:35
#fees#etfs#investor costs#competition