MMasters in Business
← All episodes
19 June 2020

Jeremy Siegel on the Stock Market Under Covid-19 (Podcast)

4Frameworks
13Insights

Listen

Frameworks in this episode

Insights & moments

The myth-busts, hot takes, explainers, and tools worth keeping.

Myth Buster· 2

Myth Buster33:42

Getting an IPO Allocation Is Not the Same as Buying Its Debut

IPO performance depends critically on the investor's entry point. Receiving shares at the offering price has historically been attractive, while purchasing once public trading begins can produce a very different result.

  • Offering-price allocations capture the initial pricing discount
  • Public buyers may enter after an immediate jump
  • Historical IPO results vary by era
  • Technology concentration improved more recent cohorts

“They're getting it at the I p O price, which is almost always good, and then there's getting it when it starts trading, and that…”

Jeremy Siegel · 34:08

“up to that point, it was it was a loser's game.”

Jeremy Siegel · 35:16
#ipos#valuation#public markets
Myth Buster35:34

Why CAPE Became Too Bearish After the Financial Crisis

Siegel argues that CAPE's ten-year average of reported earnings became distorted after accounting changes increased earnings volatility and magnified crisis-era losses. Changes in dividend behavior also weakened historical comparisons, although he maintains that valuation itself still matters.

  • CAPE relies on ten years of reported earnings
  • Accounting changes increased reported volatility
  • Financial-crisis losses depressed the rolling average
  • Dividend-policy changes complicate historical comparisons

“I said the CAPE is giving off wrong signals now,”

Jeremy Siegel · 36:09

“However, valuation matters, and I do look at what I think is normal earnings,”

Jeremy Siegel · 37:02
#cape#valuation#accounting#earnings

Hot Take· 3

Hot Take12:23

The Pandemic Permanently Advanced Technology Adoption

Siegel argues that the technology sector's strength was not merely a temporary lockdown trade. Forced experimentation showed businesses and households that remote meetings and reduced travel could remain more efficient after the virus receded.

  • COVID-19 accelerated reliance on digital tools
  • Some remote practices produced better outcomes
  • Business travel and in-person meetings may remain lower
  • Antitrust action was a larger threat to dominant technology firms

“this pandemic just made a huge shift to showing how much as a society we rely on technology,”

Jeremy Siegel · 12:48

“this shocked us into a new mode that things that some things are just better.”

Jeremy Siegel · 13:45
#technology#remote work#fang#pandemic
Hot Take26:24

Why Siegel Called the Forty-Year Bond Bull Market Over

Siegel expected Treasury yields to rise gradually as moderate inflation returned. Treasuries could retain value as short-run crisis hedges, but yields below inflation and capital losses on long-duration bonds would weaken their long-term return profile.

  • Treasuries retain negative-beta hedging demand
  • Moderate inflation can push nominal yields higher
  • Bond returns may fail to keep pace with inflation
  • Long-duration holders face capital losses as yields rise

“I see bonds as I say, I think this is low yield, and I see them creeping up continuously.”

Jeremy Siegel · 26:47

“You're going to do worse than inflation.”

Jeremy Siegel · 28:12
#bonds#treasuries#inflation#yields
Hot Take29:33

Lockdown Day Trading Replaced Sports Betting and Casinos

Siegel interprets part of the Robinhood trading surge as entertainment demand displaced from closed casinos and sports betting. He allows that investors may use a small portion of a portfolio for experimentation, but says the core should remain invested for the long term.

  • Closed gambling outlets redirected attention to stocks
  • Some traders viewed losses as an entertainment cost
  • Many new traders were unlikely to persist
  • Speculation should remain separate from core investments

“Where are they going? Oh let's go to the stock market.”

Jeremy Siegel · 30:02

“take take ten percent of your portfolio, have fun, play with it, see how you do. But you know the rest should be long term…”

Jeremy Siegel · 30:57
#day trading#robinhood#gambling#retail investors

Explainer· 5

Explainer15:01

Why the March 2020 Selloff Became So Violent

The market abruptly shifted from treating COVID-19 as a contained problem in China to fearing a global catastrophe. Poor preparation, shortages, confusing public-health guidance, and destructive shutdown implementation amplified the transition from complacency to panic.

  • Risk perception changed suddenly
  • Medical-supply shortages deepened fear
  • Public-health preparation appeared inadequate
  • Government panic reinforced market panic

“it went from complacency to panic,”

Jeremy Siegel · 15:33

“the market just absolutely in tainted with it.”

Jeremy Siegel · 16:06
#market crash#covid-19#investor psychology
Explainer23:02

Why the COVID Recession Was Structurally Different from 2008

Siegel contrasts the pandemic shock with the financial crisis, which followed excess housing construction, poor mortgage lending, collapsing home equity, and a long inventory correction. The pre-COVID economy did not contain the same production overhang, supporting the case for a faster recovery.

  • The financial crisis followed excess housing supply
  • Bad mortgage lending destroyed household equity
  • Housing starts required a prolonged adjustment
  • COVID interrupted production without the same prior excess

“what sparked the financial crisis was the first and oversupply of housing.”

Jeremy Siegel · 23:02

“there were really no excesses in terms of production before this COVID crisis.”

Jeremy Siegel · 23:33
#housing#financial crisis#recession#recovery
Explainer24:38

The Fed Can Move Credit Markets Before It Buys Anything

A credible Federal Reserve commitment can cause traders to push rates and spreads toward the announced target before substantial purchases occur. Siegel says limited implementation may still be necessary to preserve that credibility.

  • Announcements can change market pricing
  • Credibility reduces the amount of intervention required
  • The Fed targeted dysfunctional credit spreads
  • Emergency holdings can later be unwound

“The market will push the rate there.”

Jeremy Siegel · 25:04

“I I think it's a matter of credibility.”

Jeremy Siegel · 25:57
#federal reserve#credit markets#bonds#credibility
Explainer28:38

Inflation Can Make Bondholders Pay for Emergency Spending

Siegel describes moderate inflation as a mechanism for reducing the real value of government debt accumulated during the COVID response. Rather than financing the entire intervention through explicit current taxes, policymakers can allow the price level to rise and transfer part of the cost to nominal bondholders.

  • Inflation reduces the real value of fixed nominal debt
  • A cumulative price increase can offset emergency borrowing
  • Bondholders bear the resulting purchasing-power loss
  • Siegel expected moderate rather than hyperinflation

“Inflation is another way to tax people. It's it's it's attacked on the bond holders.”

Jeremy Siegel · 29:02

“Well, you inflate away some of the debt that has been floated to pay for it.”

Jeremy Siegel · 40:27
#inflation#government debt#bondholders#fiscal policy
Explainer46:19

The Pandemic Threatened Weak Colleges but Strengthened Flipped Learning

Siegel expects lower-tier colleges with weak graduate economics and heavy dependence on student loans to face contraction or closure. Elite institutions should remain strong, while recorded instruction and discussion-centered classrooms may provide a more effective hybrid model.

  • Weak schools charged tuition unsupported by graduate outcomes
  • Student debt exposed the value gap
  • Top-tier campus demand should persist
  • Basic instruction can move online before richer classroom discussion

“second and thirdain fourth tear tier schools and maybe in the second tier school gonna really have trouble.”

Jeremy Siegel · 47:01

“you would get the basic instruction online, you would come into lecture hall than ready to discuss”

Jeremy Siegel · 48:10
#education#student loans#online learning#colleges

Story· 1

Story55:12

How Milton Friedman's Work Shaped Siegel and Bernanke

Siegel identifies Milton Friedman as his intellectual mentor and highlights The Great Contraction as a foundational explanation of policy failure during the Depression. He recounts Bernanke's promise that those lessons would prevent another Great Depression and says Bernanke later implemented that playbook during the financial crisis.

  • Capitalism and Freedom first attracted Siegel to Friedman's ideas
  • The Great Contraction explained preventable monetary-policy failure
  • Bernanke publicly acknowledged Friedman's influence
  • Financial-crisis interventions applied those historical lessons

“Milton Friedman, in my intellectual mentor,”

Jeremy Siegel · 56:13

“Two years later, Bernanke had to take the playbook from that Mammoth monetary history and put it into effect and save us from the great…”

Jeremy Siegel · 1:00:32
#milton friedman#ben bernanke#great depression#monetary history

Tool· 1

Tool41:55

Siegel's Forward-Looking COVID Dashboard

Instead of relying primarily on lagging employment statistics, Siegel monitored country and state virus reports, reopening progress, therapeutics, vaccines, and mortality trends. He viewed those indicators as more useful for assessing confidence and economic normalization.

  • Employment data described the rear-view mirror
  • Virus trends offered more current signals
  • Reopening progress indicated potential activity
  • Therapeutics and vaccines affected confidence and mortality

“all the data we're getting in is rear view mirror.”

Jeremy Siegel · 42:11

“That is the forward looking it makes getting that confidence back and getting getting the therapeutics in the vaccines that excites me.”

Jeremy Siegel · 42:34
#covid-19#economic indicators#data#forecasting

Takeaway· 1

Takeaway49:22

Longer Lifespans Favor More Equity and a Modest Gold Position

Siegel expected future real stock returns to remain vastly superior to bond returns even if they fell below the historical seven-percent average. Longer retirements strengthened the case for more equity, while moderate inflation justified adding a small gold allocation.

  • Siegel projected roughly five to five-and-a-half percent real stock returns
  • Low-yield bonds weakened the traditional 60/40 mix
  • Longer lifespans increase longevity risk
  • A modest gold position can add inflation protection

“Five, five and a half? Maybe real?”

Jeremy Siegel · 49:52

“I have moved towards modest gold position.”

Jeremy Siegel · 53:02
#asset allocation#retirement#gold#equities