MMasters in Business
← All episodes
06 March 2020

Jan van Eck on Successful Thematic Investing

2Frameworks
11Insights

Listen

Frameworks in this episode

Insights & moments

The myth-busts, hot takes, explainers, and tools worth keeping.

Myth Buster· 1

Myth Buster41:31

Bond ETFs Can Be More Liquid Than Their Underlying Bonds

Direct indexing appears straightforward in equities but is difficult in fixed income because many individual bonds rarely trade and much of the market still relies on voice or message-based execution. An ETF can concentrate fragmented bond exposure into a continuously tradable instrument with a tighter spread.

  • Many bonds do not trade on a given day
  • Bond markets contain far more individual instruments than stock markets
  • Fixed-income trading remains only partly electronic
  • ETF shares can trade more efficiently than underlying bonds

“You weigh rather trade that et F at penny wide than you would the underlying bonds.”

Jan van Eck · 42:03

“Fixed income it's still a minority of trades.”

Jan van Eck · 43:14
#bonds#etfs#liquidity#direct indexing

Hot Take· 1

Hot Take24:18

Historical Ratios Fail When the Investment Universe Changes

Van Eck divides investment thinking into statistical and historical camps. He argues that apparent mean reversion can be misleading when an index’s geography, constituent mix, business economics, or market mechanisms have changed since the period used in the study.

  • Backtests assume meaningful continuity
  • Value factors can underperform for extended periods
  • Emerging-market indexes became heavily concentrated in Asia and China
  • Intangible assets weaken some traditional book-value comparisons

“I feel like we're in the Caveman era of investing, Barry.”

Jan van Eck · 25:11

“The world is changing so much all the time”

Jan van Eck · 26:07
#value investing#indexes#backtesting#market history

Explainer· 4

Explainer12:12

Green Bonds Can Finance Improvements at Polluting Companies

A green bond is evaluated according to the environmental use of its proceeds rather than the issuer’s overall purity. Van Eck argues that ESG allocations inevitably involve tradeoffs, so investors must decide which values take priority rather than demanding impossible perfection.

  • Green-bond proceeds fund environmental improvements
  • Certification is performed by a third party
  • A polluting issuer can still finance a beneficial project
  • ESG investors must rank competing values

“So bond by bond decision. It's not a company decision.”

Jan van Eck · 12:29

“There are tradeoffs in life.”

Jan van Eck · 13:20
#green bonds#esg#fixed income#environment
Explainer14:53

Why Gold Miners Lost Some of Their Commodity-Price Leverage

Gold miners behaved like options during the 1970s because commodity prices surged while production costs remained comparatively stable. In the later commodity cycle, energy costs rose and lower-grade deposits required moving more earth, reducing the earnings leverage of mining equities relative to bullion.

  • Stable costs amplified 1970s mining profits
  • Later production costs rose with commodity prices
  • Declining ore quality increased extraction requirements
  • Mining shares and bullion provide different exposures

“So the companies were like options.”

Jan van Eck · 15:18

“the last cycle there wasn't as much return leverage”

Jan van Eck · 16:05
#gold#mining#commodities#inflation
Explainer39:47

How ETF Managers Defend Shareholders During Index Rebalances

Routine ETF creations and redemptions can use in-kind securities transfers, leaving much of the trading work to authorized market participants. Index rebalances are different because predictable large purchases can invite front-running, so portfolio managers may trade before or after the formal index change.

  • In-kind transfers reduce routine portfolio trading
  • Large rebalances can reveal predictable demand
  • Managers vary execution timing to reduce exploitation
  • Protecting shareholders is the governing objective

“where we get involved is index rebalances”

Jan van Eck · 40:32

“we may buy it before the index adds it, we might buy it afterwards”

Jan van Eck · 40:54
#etfs#indexing#trading#rebalancing
Explainer53:33

Why Traditional Money-Supply Signals Stopped Explaining Markets

Van Eck argues that old monetary indicators became less useful as lending migrated beyond commercial banks. With a large non-bank credit system, central-bank actions no longer transmit solely through reserves and regulated bank balance sheets, changing the mechanism behind familiar market signals.

  • Historical indicators depended on bank-centered credit transmission
  • A large share of lending now occurs outside banks
  • Non-bank lenders are a mainstream part of the credit system
  • Central banks increasingly act through direct asset purchases

“only half of the lending is happening inside our banking system.”

Jan van Eck · 55:02

“the transmission mechanic is totally different.”

Jan van Eck · 55:13
#credit#central banks#money supply#non-bank lending

Story· 1

Story44:18

The Clear-Cut Redwood Forest That Became a Sustainable Endowment

Fred Van Eck bought nearly valueless clear-cut redwood land and allowed the forest to recover. Selective harvesting later generated charitable income while encouraging growth, and the property became the first in the United States to qualify for California carbon credits.

  • Clear-cut land was acquired cheaply
  • Regrowing redwoods restored ecological and economic value
  • Selective harvesting supported sustainable income
  • Carbon credits created an additional revenue source
  • Income funded a major gift to Purdue University

“He just bought all this redwood forest for almost nothing”

Jan van Eck · 45:30

“I'm gonna do something called selective harvesting, which is basically like weeding a forest.”

Jan van Eck · 46:02
#forestry#sustainability#carbon credits#philanthropy

Tool· 1

Tool1:07:21

Travel and Agenda-Free Dinners Reveal Changes Before Books Do

Van Eck uses travel and small dinners as informal research tools. Direct observation contextualized developments in China that were absent from contemporary reporting, while agenda-free gatherings let knowledgeable participants explore emerging changes without sales pressure.

  • Travel supplies context unavailable in published reports
  • Repeated visits reveal structural change over time
  • Small groups encourage cross-disciplinary insight
  • Removing sales agendas improves the conversation

“You can learn so much from contextualizing through travel.”

Jan van Eck · 1:07:37

“It's just let's get eight really interesting people in a room and have a conversation to see where it goes.”

Barry Ritholtz · 1:09:15
#research#travel#networking#idea dinners

Takeaway· 3

Takeaway02:24

Why Early-Career Experimentation Beats a Perfect Career Track

Van Eck did not enter the family investment firm immediately. He sampled journalism, prosecution, corporate law, banking, policy, and politics before encounters with Silicon Valley entrepreneurs revealed his interest in business and creative risk-taking.

  • Audit broadly beyond degree requirements
  • Try different working environments while young
  • Use direct experience to discover personal fit
  • Treat failed experiments as information

“I mean, just tried as many different things.”

Jan van Eck · 04:07

“Just that that creativity I didn't perceive.”

Jan van Eck · 04:54
#careers#experimentation#education#entrepreneurship
Takeaway16:13

Gold, Mining Shares, and Bitcoin Hedge Different Failure Modes

Van Eck rejects the idea that one asset is a perfect hedge against monetary-system risk. He favors a basket spanning bullion, mining shares, and bitcoin because their custody, operating, demographic, and upside characteristics differ.

  • No monetary hedge is flawless
  • Bullion avoids mining-company execution risk
  • Mining shares can add operating leverage
  • Bitcoin offers a distinct source of upside and custody risk

“Then you probably want you know, several different hedges.”

Jan van Eck · 16:30

“All of these assets have their pros and cons right, I just say buy a basket”

Jan van Eck · 18:17
#bitcoin#gold#hedging#alternative assets
Takeaway1:09:53

Financial Fitness Requires Engagement, Not Just Better Products

Van Eck identifies low saving participation as a major failure of the investment industry. Many people need human engagement and simple tools that make saving habitual, because access to sophisticated investment products does little for households that never establish savings behavior.

  • Many Americans do not save or use brokerage accounts
  • Financial guidance must address behavior and engagement
  • Small automated contributions can accumulate meaningfully
  • Financial insecurity creates persistent stress

“half of Americans don't save, They don't they don't know how to save”

Jan van Eck · 1:10:10

“If you don't have money, you have stress in your life.”

Barry Ritholtz · 1:11:06
#saving#financial literacy#behavior#financial inclusion