MMasters in Business
← All episodes
Steven Pinker03 June 2016

Interview With Steven Pinker: Masters in Business (Audio)

3Frameworks
12Insights

Listen

Frameworks in this episode

Insights & moments

The myth-busts, hot takes, explainers, and tools worth keeping.

Myth Buster· 5

Myth Buster09:48

Why Violent Headlines Do Not Prove the World Is Becoming More Violent

News reports events rather than uneventful periods of peace, so persistent coverage of violence does not reveal its underlying rate. Pinker argues that historical and global comparisons show major declines in war, homicide, and crime despite a continuous supply of alarming incidents.

  • Headlines select events rather than absences
  • Violence can fill the news even while its rate declines
  • Large peaceful regions receive little equivalent coverage
  • Historical homicide rates provide a more meaningful baseline

“you can't get an accurate picture of the world by looking at the headlines.”

Steven Pinker · 10:13

“The headlines are about things that happen, they're not about things that don't happen.”

Steven Pinker · 10:17
#violence#media#statistics#history
Myth Buster15:42

The U.S. Crime Decline Does Not Have One Clever Explanation

Pinker rejects excessive confidence in neat explanations for the large decline in American violent crime. Smarter policing, more police, and broader cultural shifts may all have contributed, but the complete causal mixture remains unknown.

  • Violent crime fell to nearly half its peak
  • Crime continued falling during the Great Recession despite contrary predictions
  • Single-factor theories such as lead or abortion may be inadequate
  • Policing and unexplained cultural changes may have acted together

“The honest answer is, no one really knows what all the causes were.”

Steven Pinker · 16:32

“it may be that a number of things went right around the same time.”

Steven Pinker · 16:44
#crime#causality#policing#united states
Myth Buster19:20

Why Tweets and Text Messages Will Not Ruin Language

People command multiple styles and adapt their language to different situations and media. Informal digital writing therefore does not automatically replace lectures, formal prose, family conversation, or ceremonial speech.

  • Writing is not one uniform activity
  • People maintain distinct styles for distinct contexts
  • A text message and a funeral oration serve different purposes
  • One medium cannot represent the trajectory of language as a whole

“we tailor our our language to the medium.”

Steven Pinker · 20:17

“Text message is going to be different from a funeral ooration.”

Steven Pinker · 20:05
#writing#digital media#language#style
Myth Buster23:05

The Split Infinitive Rule Is a Grammatical Superstition

Pinker argues that several familiar writing prohibitions were imposed through misguided analogies rather than the natural grammar of English. The rule against splitting infinitives came from Latin, while respected English writers freely ended clauses with prepositions.

  • Not every classroom rule reflects English grammar
  • Latin structure was incorrectly imposed on English infinitives
  • Splitting an infinitive can be clear and natural
  • Canonical writers violate alleged rules without producing bad English

“There's absolutely no reason to avoid a split infinitive.”

Steven Pinker · 23:30

“The whole rule came from a kind of thick witted analogy to Latin, where you can't split an infinitive.”

Steven Pinker · 23:35
#grammar#writing#english#style
Myth Buster40:52

Why CRISPR Is Unlikely to Produce Designer Genius Babies

Pinker distinguishes editing a disease-associated gene from engineering complex traits such as intelligence, musicality, or athleticism. Such traits appear to involve hundreds or thousands of genes with tiny individual effects and potentially dangerous trade-offs.

  • Complex traits do not come from one decisive gene
  • Many genes contribute tiny effects to intelligence and personality
  • A beneficial variant may also increase disease risk
  • Embryo editing offers uncertain gains alongside serious downside

“there ain't no i Q gene.”

Steven Pinker · 41:57

“There is a genetic basis to talent and personality, but seems to be distributed across hundreds or thousands of genes, each with a tiny effect,…”

Steven Pinker · 42:15
#crispr#genetics#intelligence#bioethics

Explainer· 6

Explainer04:21

Why Your Detailed Visual World Is Partly an Illusion

Human vision feels uniformly detailed, but sharp acuity occupies only the small region currently receiving direct gaze. Rapid eye movements, memory, and expectations let the brain construct the impression of a continuous, detailed scene.

  • Visual cognition interprets what the eyes detect
  • Acuity falls dramatically outside the point of gaze
  • Rapid eye movements conceal the limitations of peripheral vision
  • Expectations and memories help construct perceived continuity

“your brain constructs an illusion of a continuously detailed visual world.”

Steven Pinker · 06:28

“we rely on expectations and memories.”

Steven Pinker · 06:42
#visual cognition#perception#attention#brain
Explainer07:34

Why Words Sometimes Sound Like Their Meanings—but Usually Do Not

Some words appear to have sounds that fit their meanings, creating a limited correlation between sound and concept. Pinker argues that this effect cannot dominate language because otherwise unfamiliar languages would be immediately intelligible.

  • Some speech sounds evoke qualities associated with meaning
  • Sound symbolism produces only a limited correlation
  • Most word meanings are conventional and arbitrary
  • The effort required to learn another language demonstrates that arbitrariness

“most of the language is arbitrary, but there is a little bit of correlation between sound and meaning.”

Steven Pinker · 08:31
#language#sound symbolism#psycholinguistics
Explainer11:46

How Literacy May Have Accelerated Humanitarian Reform

Pinker proposes that cheaper printing, rising literacy, and public debate helped expand empathy and expose destructive beliefs during the Enlightenment. He treats this as a conjecture rather than a settled single-cause explanation and emphasizes the importance of free expression.

  • Printing costs fell before broad industrial prosperity arrived
  • Books, newspapers, pamphlets, and urban discussion connected more people
  • Reading other viewpoints may broaden empathy
  • Open criticism can filter false and toxic ideas
  • Educated intellectuals can still advance destructive ideologies

“It's harder to dehumanize people when you read their words, when you see what life was like from their point of view.”

Steven Pinker · 14:07

“when you have freedom of speech, freedom of expression, so you don't get thrown in jail by criticizing a bad idea, then it's more likely…”

Steven Pinker · 15:22
#literacy#enlightenment#free speech#violence
Explainer27:35

Why an Involuntary Expression Can Make a Message Credible

Facial expression and tone can reveal whether a threat, promise, or emotion is sincere because most people cannot control these signals perfectly. Genuine smiles, for example, tend to engage the eyes as well as the mouth.

  • Expressions supplement spoken claims with credibility signals
  • Anger can make a threat appear more sincere
  • Involuntary signals are difficult to imitate consistently
  • Genuine and performed smiles often recruit different facial patterns

“threats are more credible when they're delivered with an angry expression and tone of voice, because they are involuntary”

Steven Pinker · 27:57

“the sincere smile as along with a crinkling of the eyes, not just the mouth in a U shape.”

Steven Pinker · 28:43
#facial expressions#credibility#communication#emotion
Explainer37:28

What the Broken-Windows Effect Actually Claims

Visible disorder may communicate that local rules are not enforced, increasing the likelihood of further violations. Pinker says experiments support some effect from restoring order but cautions that it cannot receive all the credit for crime reductions.

  • Disrepair acts as a social signal
  • Graffiti and turnstile jumping can imply weak enforcement
  • Improving visible order may reduce crime
  • The effect is contributory rather than a complete explanation

“if a neighborhood shows signs of disrepair, the famous broken windows, graffiti, turnstile jumping, and so on, then that conveys the message that that this…”

Steven Pinker · 37:33

“It doesn't deserve all the credit, but it may be deserved part of it.”

Steven Pinker · 37:56
#broken windows#crime#social norms#policing
Explainer38:06

Why Great Powers Largely Stopped Fighting One Another

Pinker describes the Long Peace as the post-Korean War absence of direct war among great powers. He points to trade, stable borders, democracy, and declining glorification of military sacrifice as reinforcing explanations rather than one definitive cause.

  • Great-power warfare was historically common
  • Trade raises the cost of attacking customers and supply chains
  • International norms discourage conquest and forced border changes
  • Democracies are somewhat less likely to fight one another
  • Modern societies place greater value on individual life

“When you when there's more trade, there is less of an incentive to go to war.”

Steven Pinker · 39:45

“You don't kill your customers because your supply chain or your supply chain exactly”

Steven Pinker · 39:52
#war#trade#democracy#long peace

Takeaway· 1

Takeaway49:21

Pinker’s Advice to Students Considering a Difficult Academic Career

Pinker advises genuinely passionate and capable students not to abandon intellectual work merely because the academic job market is discouraging. Turnover continues even in contracting fields, and deep motivation makes the sustained work required more achievable.

  • Passion must be strong enough to sustain intensive work
  • Contracting fields still experience retirements and turnover
  • Capability and dedication matter alongside enthusiasm
  • Law, finance, and consulting should not become automatic defaults

“if it excites you enough that it doesn't feel like work but it feels like play, there will always be openings.”

Steven Pinker · 50:20

“it really is still possible to make a career in what you what you love.”

Steven Pinker · 50:38
#academia#career advice#passion#students