MMasters in Business
← All episodes
Hubert Joly24 September 2021

Hubert Joly on the Heart of Business (Podcast)

4Frameworks
12Insights

Listen

Frameworks in this episode

Insights & moments

The myth-busts, hot takes, explainers, and tools worth keeping.

Myth Buster· 2

Myth Buster31:56

Best Buy Did Not Need Amazon to Lose

Joly argues that companies should focus on customers and becoming their best selves rather than obsessing over competitors. Best Buy neutralized Amazon's online advantages while partnering with it where collaboration could create value, including an exclusive Fire TV arrangement.

  • Competitors can also become strategic partners.
  • Matching table-stakes capabilities can turn a disadvantage into a draw.
  • Unique assets should receive more attention than competitive obsession.
  • Zero-sum thinking can prevent valuable stakeholder outcomes.

“you're obsessed about your customers and becoming the best version of yourself you can be.”

Hubert Joly · 33:49

“You get to collaborate and create great outcomes.”

Hubert Joly · 34:38
#competition#amazon#partnerships#strategy
Myth Buster48:41

Joly Says Stakeholder Capitalism Is Not Socialism

Joly argues that shareholder primacy and top-down scientific management have become harmful when profit is treated as the only objective. His alternative is a purpose-led business that serves customers responsibly, puts people at the center, rejects zero-sum tradeoffs, and treats profit as an outcome.

  • Accounting profit omits important environmental and organizational effects.
  • Profit is a result that does not fully describe organizational health.
  • Serving stakeholders can generate strong shareholder returns.
  • Purpose-led business remains compatible with capitalism.
  • Carrot-and-stick incentives can undermine intrinsic motivation.

“the obsession with profits being the only thing that matters has proven to be poisonous”

Hubert Joly · 48:49

“This is not about socialism. This is about doing something good in the world that's gonna be responding to needs of customers in a way…”

Hubert Joly · 50:19
#capitalism#stakeholders#profit#purpose

Hot Take· 2

Hot Take05:02

The Cultural Difference Joly Sees in Unsolved Problems

Joly contrasts what he sees as French skepticism toward problems nobody has solved with an American instinct to treat them as opportunities. He credits this optimism as one reason he loves living in the United States.

  • Cultural assumptions influence responses to difficult problems.
  • Skepticism asks who is qualified to try.
  • Optimism asks whether a new solution is possible.

“if a problem has never been solved, you know, immediately a frantic Oh, this is interesting, let's see whether we can solve it.”

Hubert Joly · 05:23
#optimism#culture#innovation
Hot Take1:03:49

The Quest for Perfection Can Make Leaders Cruel

Joly warns that perfectionism is unattainable and can make leaders harsh toward themselves and everyone around them. Better leadership requires openness about struggles, mutual support, humility, and kindness.

  • No leader is perfect.
  • Unrealistic self-demands spread to expectations of colleagues.
  • Sharing struggles makes mutual support possible.
  • Kindness supports sustainable leadership better than perfectionism.

“The quest for perfection, you know, can be very dangerous, can be evil”

Hubert Joly · 1:03:52

“you have to relact and be kind with yourself and others around you and be able to open up and share what you're struggling with”

Hubert Joly · 1:04:08
#perfectionism#leadership#kindness#vulnerability

Explainer· 2

Explainer26:57

Why Geek Squad Became Best Buy's Cross-Vendor Advantage

Geek Squad differentiated Best Buy by extending the relationship beyond a product sale. Its technicians could advise, install, troubleshoot, and diagnose problems spanning internet service, routers, streaming devices, televisions, and content providers.

  • Technology customers often need help after purchasing hardware.
  • Service creates differentiation that pure product availability cannot.
  • Cross-vendor diagnosis is valuable because failures can occur at many points.
  • Geek Squad grew to roughly twenty thousand employees.

“bas by it's not just in the business of selling you something”

Hubert Joly · 27:32

“we're gonna be able to help you across a lot of these vendors and so that's a big differentiator for for the company.”

Hubert Joly · 28:13
#geek-squad#services#customer-experience#technology
Explainer53:37

Why Joly Treated Board Diversity as a Nonnegotiable Constraint

Joly presents diversity as both a commercial necessity and a moral responsibility. Best Buy sought directors with strong skills while explicitly requiring a diverse candidate pool, even warning recruiters that the company would change firms if they claimed qualified Black candidates could not be found.

  • Teams should reflect the customers and communities they serve.
  • Language and cultural representation directly affect retail performance.
  • Visible representation expands what others believe is possible.
  • Recruiting constraints can force search firms to broaden candidate pools.
  • Board composition can signal organizational direction from the top.

“We have to represent the diversity of the customers we we serve. If we don't, bad things happen.”

Hubert Joly · 54:20

“people cannot be what they cannot see.”

Hubert Joly · 55:18
#diversity#boards#inclusion#representation

Story· 1

Story20:43

How Best Buy Turned Showrooming Into Vendor-Funded Showcasing

Best Buy neutralized showrooming by matching Amazon's prices and letting store employees authorize matches immediately. It then reframed stores as valuable showcases for technology manufacturers, creating branded store-within-a-store partnerships that improved customer experiences and offset physical-retail costs.

  • Price matching removed a major reason to leave the store without buying.
  • Immediate ownership gave physical retail an advantage.
  • Technology vendors needed experiential spaces for expensive innovations.
  • Samsung's store-within-a-store agreement became a model for other partnerships.
  • Vendor economics helped offset Best Buy's cost disadvantage.

“we were going to take price off the table by aligning up places with Amazon and giving the Blue Shirt the authority on the spot…”

Hubert Joly · 21:06

“you need a place where to showcase your products, right because you spend billions of dollars on R and d”

Hubert Joly · 22:10
#retail#showrooming#partnerships#best-buy#omnichannel

Takeaway· 5

Takeaway03:10

Why Strong Relationships Quietly Compounded Joly's Career

Joly says several major career moves arose through relationships with people who had seen his work and remained friends. His practical lesson is to perform well where you are and avoid needlessly damaging relationships along the way.

  • Career opportunities often arrive through accumulated trust.
  • Strong performance in the current role creates future optionality.
  • Avoiding unnecessary interpersonal damage preserves long-term relationships.

“every move was a move that was based on it was there was somebody with whom I had developed a relationship that played a critical…”

Hubert Joly · 03:13

“try to minimize the number of people you annoy, your irritate along the way, and and try to focus on doing a great job where…”

Hubert Joly · 03:41
#career#relationships#reputation
Takeaway14:14

Best Buy Rebuilt Credibility by Saying Less and Doing More

Joly rejects the idea that managing public, private-equity, or family shareholders is fundamentally different because each group consists of people with expectations and needs. At Best Buy, credibility returned through transparency, restrained promises, consistent delivery, and progress updates.

  • Treat shareholders as human stakeholders rather than abstractions.
  • Listen carefully to investor questions.
  • Monitor the ratio between promises and completed actions.
  • Share conditions, opportunities, plans, and subsequent progress transparently.

“we're gonna say less and do more, and that's how we're gonna build our credibility.”

Hubert Joly · 15:41

“be very transparent, share our situation, the opportunities, we saw what we're gonna do, and then we updated them in our progress”

Hubert Joly · 15:48
#shareholders#credibility#investor-relations
Takeaway35:39

Joly Used Another Company's Board to Become a Better CEO

Joly joined Ralph Lauren's board partly to understand board members' needs and observe how another CEO managed the relationship. As a CEO, he wanted directors with complementary expertise who could act as sounding boards rather than attempting to run the company.

  • Serving on another board exposes a CEO to the director's perspective.
  • Boards should complement rather than duplicate management capabilities.
  • Preparation for a board meeting can produce much of its value.
  • Directors are most useful as expert sounding boards, not substitute executives.

“The reason why I was interested in joining another board was to try to become a better CEO in the relationship with boards”

Hubert Joly · 35:49

“I was not looking for the board to give me all of the entries and do my job right”

Hubert Joly · 37:26
#boards#governance#ceo#learning
Takeaway40:10

Why Reading Alone Is Not Enough at Harvard Business School

Joly explains that Harvard Business School relies heavily on case studies rather than mandatory book reading. He supports reading but argues that practicing decisions through cases creates deeper learning than passively consuming ideas.

  • Case studies require learners to engage with decisions.
  • Practice strengthens learning beyond reading alone.
  • Books can support learning without replacing application.

“it's hard to learn just from reading reading.”

Hubert Joly · 40:46

“it's by practicing that you really learned, right.”

Hubert Joly · 40:51
#education#case-method#harvard
Takeaway1:04:39

Leaders Must Put On Their Own Oxygen Mask First

Using the familiar airline safety instruction, Joly says leaders must care for their own physical and emotional condition before they can reliably support others. He recommends meditation, exercise, flexibility, and asking trusted people for help during difficult periods.

  • Self-care is a prerequisite for helping others sustainably.
  • Meditation and exercise can preserve leadership capacity.
  • Trusted friends and a personal board of directors provide support.
  • Asking for help is part of responsible leadership.

“if the oxygen mask comes down, put it on yourself first before you help out it.”

Hubert Joly · 1:04:43

“taking care of yourself as a leader”

Hubert Joly · 1:04:52
#self-care#resilience#leadership#wellbeing