MMasters in Business
← All episodes
Ricky Sandler22 August 2024

From GameStop to Meme Stocks with Ricky Sandler

4Frameworks
15Insights

Listen

Frameworks in this episode

Insights & moments

The myth-busts, hot takes, explainers, and tools worth keeping.

Myth Buster· 1

Myth Buster36:33

Why the Original GameStop Short-Squeeze Thesis No Longer Fits

The original GameStop squeeze depended on extremely high short interest and a constrained float. After the company issued billions of dollars in equity and short sellers covered, short interest fell to roughly 9%, undermining the claim that another inevitable mother-of-all-short-squeezes remained embedded in the stock.

  • Original short interest may have reached 80% to 90%
  • GameStop substantially increased its share float
  • Many short sellers covered
  • Short interest later fell to about 9%

“So so now your short interest is nine percent. Like that's fairly low as as far as short interests go.”

Ricky Sandler · 37:39

“So you don't really have a thesis if your thesis is mother of you know, moass with rocket ships right.”

Ricky Sandler · 37:45
#gamestop#meme stocks#short squeeze#retail trading

Hot Take· 2

Hot Take19:51

The Bigger Market-Structure Shift Happened Inside Active Investing

Sandler agrees that passive ownership has grown dramatically but argues that the active side has changed just as consequentially. Bottom-up investors have been displaced by quant funds, pod shops, thematic strategies, systematic investors, and retail traders operating on shorter horizons.

  • Passive market share rose from roughly 25% to 60%
  • Today's active cohort is not dominated by bottom-up analysts
  • Many marginal price setters trade factors, themes, or short horizons
  • Daily price action often has little connection to company research

“But you know, our view is that markets are very different and the people setting prices over the short run are very different than they…”

Ricky Sandler · 20:01

“And so on most days the price action you see in a stock is being driven by somebody who is not doing bottoms up research.”

Ricky Sandler · 20:52
#market structure#passive investing#active management#price discovery
Hot Take38:30

Meme-Stock Trading Is Coordinated Price Action, Not Amateur Research

Sandler distinguishes modern meme-stock campaigns from the grassroots company research found on early internet message boards. He characterizes coordinated buying as an effort to initiate price gains that force short covering and attract momentum-sensitive investors, creating further price action.

  • Mobile access and free trading expanded retail influence
  • Modern campaigns can coordinate simultaneous buying
  • Rising prices can force shorts to cover
  • Price movement itself attracts additional buyers

“This is actually bullying. This is coordinated efforts to all come in and try to buy the stock at the same time.”

Ricky Sandler · 39:05

“And so we're going to create the price action that's going to create further price action.”

Ricky Sandler · 39:19
#meme stocks#retail investors#market manipulation#momentum

Explainer· 4

Explainer09:47

Inside Eminence Capital's 150/50 Alpha-Extension Portfolio

The 150/50 strategy maintains 100% net market exposure while adding a market-neutral sleeve with 50 extra points of long exposure and 50 points of shorts. Investors receive conventional market exposure plus two potential alpha sources: long selection and the long-short spread.

  • The portfolio is 150% long and 50% short
  • Net market exposure remains 100% long
  • The neutral sleeve adds another source of alpha
  • The product is designed as a long-equity replacement

“There's the alpha on our lungs what we would do if we had one hundred percent long portfolio, and then you add a fifty by…”

Ricky Sandler · 10:42
#alpha extension#portfolio construction#long-short#asset allocation
Explainer11:39

A Fee Structure That Charges More Only When Alpha Appears

Eminence's alpha-extension product charges a 50-basis-point fixed fee and 30% of returns above the MSCI World benchmark. Sandler presents this as alignment: clients pay a modest fee when the fund fails to outperform and share more generously when it produces substantial alpha.

  • The benchmark is MSCI World
  • The fixed fee is 50 basis points
  • The performance fee is 30% of alpha
  • The structure separates payment for beta from payment for skill

“So if we don't beat the market, you pay us a pretty low fee fifty basis points. If we crush the market, you pay us…”

Ricky Sandler · 12:05

“It's a fair sharing of fees and a good alignment.”

Ricky Sandler · 12:10
#fees#alpha#benchmarks#alignment
Explainer15:31

Three Ways Higher Interest Rates Improve the Short Opportunity Set

Higher rates restore meaningful discounting of distant profits, impose discipline on businesses that previously survived on cheap capital, and generate cash rebates on short proceeds. Sandler argues that these effects make valuation and fundamentals more consequential even though shorting remains operationally difficult.

  • Future earnings must be discounted at a nonzero rate
  • Higher capital costs discourage profitless competition
  • Business economics become more rational
  • Short proceeds can earn a meaningful credit rebate

“So now we have valuation is going to matter and fundamentals will start to come into play.”

Ricky Sandler · 17:00

“You know, we're getting five percent on our shorts, so you're getting paid to wait.”

Ricky Sandler · 17:07
#interest rates#short selling#valuation#cost of capital
Explainer24:40

How P&L Triggers Turn Narratives Into Forced Deleveraging

Narrative-driven portfolios are often paired with rigid loss limits. When performance deteriorates, managers cut risk regardless of whether the underlying thesis changed, amplifying moves caused by themes and positioning rather than fundamentals.

  • Short-term P&L can dictate portfolio changes
  • Platform managers may face automatic capital cuts
  • Forced deleveraging is backward-looking
  • Mechanical risk reactions amplify nonfundamental volatility

“And to your point, the add investing is also add with my P and L. If I start to lose P and L, I move”

Ricky Sandler · 25:28

“So that creates, on top of the narrative behavior that's almost trigger driven and exacerbates this volatility.”

Ricky Sandler · 26:32
#deleveraging#volatility#risk limits#pod shops

Story· 1

Story48:16

How a Passive Entain Investment Became a Board-Level Turnaround

Eminence initially viewed Entain as a strong strategic asset with weak management rather than an activist target. After concluding that leadership and capital allocation were substantially worse than expected, Sandler chose board involvement over selling and says the company subsequently improved leadership and decision-making.

  • Entain owns major international gambling brands
  • Eminence did not enter expecting activism
  • Weak leadership and capital allocation changed the calculation
  • The board appointed a new permanent CEO
  • Sandler describes the engagement as cooperative rather than combative

“We never go into a situation expecting to be activists.”

Ricky Sandler · 49:35

“What happens from time to time is you go into situation you think management's a B, maybe a B minus, and it turns out you're…”

Ricky Sandler · 49:39
#entain#activism#governance#turnaround

Tool· 1

Tool59:41

Turn Early-Career Contacts Into a Long-Term Knowledge Network

Sandler advises young professionals to cultivate relationships before they need assistance. He recommends staying in touch with useful notes, categorizing contacts, and preserving access to expertise that may become relevant years after the first meeting.

  • Record valuable contacts early
  • Maintain relationships without immediately asking for favors
  • Send relevant articles or updates periodically
  • Categorize contacts by knowledge and industry
  • Use the network to accelerate future research

“manage your rolodex really proactively.”

Ricky Sandler · 59:41

“don't just call them when you want something from them.”

Ricky Sandler · 1:00:38
#networking#career development#relationships#research

Takeaway· 6

Takeaway06:31

Why Downside Protection Creates Offensive Capacity

Sandler says the 1998 crisis exposed the weakness of superficial hedges and pushed Eminence toward single-stock shorting. Protecting capital during dislocations creates the financial and psychological capacity to buy when other investors are selling emotionally.

  • Light hedges failed during the 1998 crisis
  • Single-stock shorts became a core pillar at Eminence
  • Capital protection creates dry powder
  • Major dislocations can offer the best future return opportunities

“One of the things that I felt in ninety eight was the inability to lean into a dislocated market because we weren't protecting capital well…”

Ricky Sandler · 07:06

“One of the things I've seen throughout my entire career is that being offensive when there's dislocation, you are planting the greatest seeds possible.”

Ricky Sandler · 07:36
#shorting#risk management#dislocations#hedge funds
Takeaway27:12

Why Investors Keep Extrapolating the Last Successful Cycle

The 2000s favored long-short stock picking, while the post-2012 period rewarded passive exposure to the S&P 500. Sandler argues that investors repeatedly treat the latest regime as permanent even when rates and market conditions have changed.

  • Long-short strategies excelled during the lost decade
  • Passive equity exposure dominated the following cycle
  • Markets move through distinct phases
  • Capital allocators commonly extrapolate recent returns

“All this history has shown me is both markets go through cycles, and investors, whether you like it or not, are backward looking, return looking…”

Ricky Sandler · 29:05

“They rarely look forward.”

Ricky Sandler · 29:17
#market cycles#behavioral finance#long-short#indexing
Takeaway41:39

Three Billion Dollars Saved GameStop's Balance Sheet, Not Its Business

GameStop used renewed meme-stock demand to issue shares at prices Sandler considered far above intrinsic value. The cash sharply reduced bankruptcy risk, but he argues that it did not solve the structural decline of a mall-based retailer selling products increasingly distributed online.

  • The equity issuance raised roughly $3 billion
  • The company gained a long financial runway
  • Bankruptcy risk fell materially
  • The operating model still requires a successful reinvention

“They bought themselves a hugely. They could try anything they That company will not run out of money for the longest period of time.”

Ricky Sandler · 42:03

“That doesn't mean that. This is a successful business.”

Ricky Sandler · 47:57
#gamestop#capital raising#retail disruption#turnarounds
Takeaway51:20

Investment Committees Often Ask the Wrong Questions About Returns

Serving on the University of Wisconsin Foundation investment committee lets Sandler observe institutional allocation from the client side. He says sophisticated committees can still focus too heavily on historical returns without examining repeatability, cycle exposure, or the risk required to produce them.

  • Historical returns do not establish manager skill
  • Committees should examine how returns were produced
  • Repeatability matters more than headline performance
  • Cycle exposure and embedded risk require explicit evaluation

“Very sophisticated people coming together on committees looking backward looking returns often don't ask the rigorous questions about how did you deliver those returns?”

Ricky Sandler · 52:35

“Are they repeatable? Was this a cycle? How much risk did it take in there?”

Ricky Sandler · 52:45
#endowments#manager selection#asset allocation#governance
Takeaway55:25

The Longevity Playbook Is Simpler Than the Industry Makes It Sound

Sandler reduces much of modern longevity advice to movement, healthy eating, sunlight, strength training, meaningful work, and strong relationships. He highlights small routine changes, particularly replacing some cardio with strength work and spending more time walking outdoors.

  • Move regularly
  • Eat less and choose healthy food
  • Get sunlight and walk
  • Prioritize strength training
  • Maintain meaningful work and relationships

“Move, eat less and eat healthy, get sunlight, have meaningful work and meaningful relationships, some strength training Like that's it, you know”

Ricky Sandler · 55:28

“there's all this data and it's not that complicated”

Ricky Sandler · 55:41
#longevity#health#strength training#habits
Takeaway1:01:06

Ask Executives How They Think, Not What Next Year Will Be

Sandler says he learned not to take executive and board statements at face value because leaders have imperfect knowledge and personal incentives. He now researches the business independently and uses management meetings to evaluate judgment, capital allocation, motivation, and trustworthiness.

  • Executives may be biased, mistaken, or deceptive
  • Independent company research should precede management reliance
  • Management interviews should reveal thought processes
  • Capital-allocation judgment is more useful than precise forecasts
  • Short-term stock incentives can conflict with long-term business value

“I'll do my own research on the business. I'm not going to rely on you to tell me what the company is going to do…”

Ricky Sandler · 1:01:48

“I want to know how you think. I want to know how you allocate capital.”

Ricky Sandler · 1:01:54
#management#due diligence#capital allocation#incentives