MMasters in Business
← All episodes
David Enrich29 March 2018

David Enrich Discusses the Libor Scandal

2Frameworks
11Insights

Listen

Frameworks in this episode

Insights & moments

The myth-busts, hot takes, explainers, and tools worth keeping.

Myth Buster· 1

Myth Buster52:22

Financial Complexity Is Often Manufactured, Not Inevitable

Enrich argues that finance has benefited from making understandable mechanisms appear inaccessible through acronyms, jargon, and unnecessary complexity. Opacity lets the industry mystify customers and defend higher fees, while narrative journalism can make the underlying mechanics accessible.

  • Financial institutions benefit from information asymmetry
  • Acronyms and jargon can exaggerate genuine complexity
  • Simple and transparent products are harder to price at a premium
  • Narrative characters help general audiences engage with technical finance

“the finance industry over the past twenty years has done a really good job at kind of cloaking itself in opacity”

David Enrich · 52:22

“They they have thrived on this lack of transparency and this kind of the mystification of the banking industry.”

David Enrich · 52:43
#financial literacy#jargon#transparency#journalism

Hot Take· 2

Hot Take13:47

Derivatives Turned Libor's Conflict of Interest Into a Crisis

Embedding Libor in derivatives gave bank traders enormous financial exposure to a benchmark their own institutions helped set. Traders had warned regulators that this combination of subjective submissions, weak oversight, and profit incentives invited manipulation.

  • Banks both submitted Libor estimates and traded on the result
  • Derivatives dramatically increased the profit incentive
  • Libor was not directly supervised by central banks or financial regulators
  • Traders warned the CFTC about manipulation risk

“It was the introduction of library into the derivatives market”

David Enrich · 13:51

“if you give banks a huge profit incentive to manipulate something. Guess what they're going to manipulate it.”

David Enrich · 14:32
#derivatives#conflicts of interest#regulation#libor
Hot Take1:02:36

Why Readers Will Pay for Journalism They Cannot Get Elsewhere

Enrich rejects free commoditized content as a sustainable media model. He sees a promising future for distinctive reporting, localized expertise, and digitally creative storytelling that delivers value readers cannot obtain from interchangeable news summaries.

  • Commoditized information is difficult to monetize
  • Readers pay for distinctive and trustworthy reporting
  • Mobile audiences require new storytelling formats
  • Multidisciplinary teams can combine reporting, graphics, code, audio, and video
  • Localized sports coverage demonstrates the value of specialized content

“what doesn't work is giving away commoditized content for free. That's like, that's not a business model.”

David Enrich · 1:04:03

“You just need to do things that are valuable and not commoditized and people will pay for”

David Enrich · 1:05:19
#journalism#media business#subscriptions#digital storytelling

Explainer· 3

Explainer03:42

Why Libor Became the World's Most Important Number

Libor set rates for adjustable mortgages, credit cards, student loans, corporate debt, municipal borrowing, and an enormous derivatives market. Its influence extended from everyday consumer payments to speculative positions with trillions of dollars in notional value.

  • Libor stood for the London Interbank Offered Rate
  • Consumer and institutional debts were commonly priced from Libor
  • Derivatives represented the benchmark's largest exposure
  • Tiny benchmark movements could produce major trading gains or losses

“It sets interest rates on all sorts of debt all over the world.”

David Enrich · 04:05

“And the biggest part is not the just normal debt, it's derivatives”

David Enrich · 04:26
#libor#interest rates#derivatives#debt
Explainer07:04

How Banks Turned Estimates Into the Daily Libor Fix

Panel banks estimated their borrowing costs across currencies and durations around lunchtime in London. Administrators removed the highest and lowest submissions and averaged the rest, producing a benchmark that looked systematic despite relying on subjective estimates.

  • Banks submitted estimated interbank borrowing costs
  • Submissions covered multiple currencies and loan durations
  • Extreme estimates were discarded
  • The remaining estimates were averaged into Libor
  • The process originated in a pre-computer workflow of internal phone calls

“All those numbers get smushed together, the high estimates and the lowest mints get booted out, and the rest are averaged in presto, you've got…”

David Enrich · 08:19

“This became a number that was being pulled more or less out of thin air by bankers at a low level.”

David Enrich · 09:58
#libor#benchmarks#banking#market structure
Explainer33:17

Why Tom Hayes Became the Scandal's Primary Fall Guy

Hayes left thousands of explicit written requests and therefore offered prosecutors an unusually easy case. Enrich argues that risk-averse authorities concentrated on this evidence-rich target while largely avoiding senior figures who knew about, condoned, or sometimes joined the conduct.

  • Hayes repeatedly documented manipulation requests
  • His written trail made conviction comparatively straightforward
  • A small number of alleged confederates were charged and acquitted
  • Authorities did not aggressively pursue senior management
  • Personal prosecution of executives could have created a stronger deterrent

“Hayes was stupid and naive, and he did everything in writing.”

David Enrich · 33:46

“prosecutors and regulators are a little bit lazy. They wanted to nail some people, but you know, they don't really want to take risks.”

David Enrich · 34:08
#prosecution#accountability#tom hayes#financial crime

Story· 3

Story04:50

How a Loan to the Shah of Iran Helped Inspire Libor

Libor's precursor emerged from the challenge of pricing a syndicated loan involving banks with different funding costs. A floating mechanism allowed the interest rate to change as those costs changed, protecting lenders from being trapped in an unprofitable long-term loan.

  • A Greek bank arranged an $80 million syndicated loan to the Shah of Iran
  • Participating banks had different borrowing costs
  • An average funding cost offered a shared reference point
  • A floating rate transferred changing funding costs into the loan price

“the innovation here that they would have a mechanism where the interest rate would fluctuate over time based on the bank's funding costs.”

David Enrich · 06:41
#libor#banking history#syndicated loans#iran
Story26:35

How Tom Hayes Used Brokers to Expand Libor Manipulation

Tom Hayes could influence his own bank's Libor submitter, but brokers gave him access to contacts at other panel banks. They circulated requests to move submissions up or down, extending his influence beyond UBS and creating the network at the heart of the scandal.

  • Hayes made large bets sensitive to tiny Libor movements
  • UBS traders openly requested favorable submissions
  • Brokers maintained relationships across multiple panel banks
  • Hayes pioneered using brokers to coordinate wider influence
  • Manipulating Libor was widespread, but Hayes pursued it relentlessly

“hey, mate, I need libor up today. Can you please move UBS submission up by as much as you can or move it down by…”

David Enrich · 27:32

“the introduction of the brokers was something that Hayes. Hayes pioneered and that was really his innovation.”

David Enrich · 28:47
#tom hayes#brokers#libor manipulation#ubs
Story29:48

The Midnight Message That Opened Tom Hayes's Life to a Reporter

After Enrich contacted a former classmate of Hayes, an unknown number sent him an extraordinary message claiming the scandal reached much higher. A planned station meeting was canceled, but the exchange began a years-long relationship that gave Enrich intimate access to Hayes and his family.

  • Hayes was already criminally charged and unlikely to speak publicly
  • A former classmate passed Enrich's number to him
  • Hayes initially proposed meeting outside a Burger King at Victoria station
  • His lawyer wife stopped the meeting
  • The contact developed into extensive access during Hayes's prosecution

“this goes much much higher than me. Not even the Justice Department knows the full story.”

David Enrich · 31:42

“that was the start of what became a year's long relationship I had with Tom Hayes.”

David Enrich · 32:31
#journalism#tom hayes#reporting#spider network

Takeaway· 2

Takeaway46:10

How Executive Behavior Becomes Cultural Permission

Enrich came to see bank culture as a concrete driver of conduct rather than consultant jargon. When senior executives pushed boundaries and behaved recklessly, employees interpreted that behavior as permission to take similar risks throughout the organization.

  • Hayes worked in institutions that explicitly encouraged envelope pushing
  • Employees take behavioral cues from senior executives
  • Risk tolerance differs meaningfully between banks
  • Cultures that permit leaving money on the table may avoid existential mistakes
  • Quarterly profit pressure encourages institutions to increase risk

“the degree to which culture at banks matters and has real world impacts.”

David Enrich · 46:16

“If that person is doing stuff that is just nuts, you're gonna get the message that it's okay to be nuts.”

David Enrich · 47:10
#bank culture#leadership#risk management#wall street
Takeaway1:06:44

Aspiring Journalists Should Build a Scarce Skill First

Rather than aiming only for a prestigious publication, Enrich advises new journalists to develop a specialization that differentiates them. That advantage might be source development, writing, programming, audio, video, or another capability a newsroom needs.

  • Prestigious employers should not be the sole career objective
  • Source development can be a defensible professional skill
  • Technical and multimedia capabilities expand reporting options
  • A clear specialization helps a journalist stand apart

“Develop a skill that sets you apart”

David Enrich · 1:06:50

“Don't go the route of just aiming to be at the Wall Street Journal or the New York Times, go develop some specialization.”

David Enrich · 1:07:10
#journalism careers#specialization#skills#career advice