MMasters in Business
← All episodes
27 February 2020

Danielle DiMartino Booth on What’s Wrong With the Fed

3Frameworks
10Insights

Listen

Frameworks in this episode

Insights & moments

The myth-busts, hot takes, explainers, and tools worth keeping.

Myth Buster· 1

Myth Buster41:59

The Inflation Metric Fed Staff Said Their Models Needed

DiMartino Booth criticizes the Fed's reliance on PCE inflation, particularly its treatment of housing and healthcare costs. She recounts an internal exchange in which changing the measure was resisted because existing models would break, despite post-crisis debate over incorporating real estate and financial-asset prices.

  • PCE and CPI can understate important household costs
  • Owner-equivalent rent can behave counterintuitively as home prices rise
  • Medicare and Medicaid reimbursement inputs affect measured healthcare inflation
  • Fed officials debated improving inflation measures after the crisis
  • No substantial reform followed that internal debate

“well, if we don't use it, our models are going to break.”

Unidentified Fed staffer, quoted by Danielle DiMartino Booth · 44:21

“This is how we make monetary policy in America. Crap in, crap out.”

Jim Bullard, quoted by Danielle DiMartino Booth · 44:30
#inflation#pce#cpi#fed models

Hot Take· 2

Hot Take30:39

Did the Employment Mandate Push the Fed Off Mission?

DiMartino Booth argues that the Fed should primarily preserve the currency's purchasing power and that the employment mandate encouraged prolonged accommodation. In her view, efforts to pull the final workers into employment came at the expense of financial stability and expanded the central bank's remit beyond what monetary policy can reliably accomplish.

  • She defines currency stability as the Fed's core role
  • She attributes mission creep to the employment mandate
  • Lower-for-longer policy may prioritize marginal employment gains over financial stability
  • The host challenges whether market support has become an unofficial third mandate

“I would think that the best role for the FED to play is making sure that the dollar you pull out of your wallet, Ay,…”

Danielle DiMartino Booth · 30:42

“But that second employment mandate is what has caused the fed's mission creep and the lower for longer.”

Danielle DiMartino Booth · 32:18
#fed mandate#employment#financial stability#monetary policy
Hot Take1:21:20

Why Investment-Grade Labels May Not Protect Bond Investors

DiMartino Booth warns that management pressure can preserve investment-grade ratings for questionable issuers. The host broadens the criticism, comparing rating agencies with conflicted stock analysts and arguing that their commercial allegiance lies with bond underwriters rather than end investors.

  • Ratings can be influenced by issuer and management pressure
  • Investment-grade bond funds may hold securities investors would reject individually
  • The issuer-paid model creates a structural conflict
  • Portfolio labels can create false reassurance for retail investors

“the management is twisting arms to maintain investment grade ratings. I'm like, no, no, thank you, not in my portfolio.”

Danielle DiMartino Booth · 1:21:43

“They're not here for you, the bond buyer. There there for the bonds underwriter.”

Barry Ritholtz · 1:22:09
#credit ratings#corporate bonds#bond etfs#conflicts

Explainer· 3

Explainer21:43

How Cheap Money Keeps Zombie Corporations Alive

The conversation distinguishes rescued banks from heavily indebted companies that cannot withstand even a short interruption in revenue. DiMartino Booth argues that suppressed rates interrupt normal default cycles, preserve inefficient capacity, and prevent new competitors from replacing failed firms.

  • Zombie corporations carry unsustainable debt loads
  • Cheap refinancing allows weak companies to survive longer
  • The share of listed zombie companies was described as roughly double its historical norm
  • Bankruptcy can remove inefficient capacity and make room for innovation

“We knew at the time that we were creating zombies.”

Danielle DiMartino Booth · 21:55

“They couldn't last like one or two if the coronavirus doesn't go away, we're going to have a handful of companies that go poof into…”

Danielle DiMartino Booth · 24:21
#zombie companies#corporate debt#bankruptcy#interest rates
Explainer55:35

Why the 2018 Credit Shutdown Mattered More Than Falling Stocks

DiMartino Booth argues that Jerome Powell's late-2018 pivot was driven less by equity prices than by dysfunction in corporate credit. GE's downgrade, a prolonged high-yield issuance shutdown, ETF redemptions, and illiquid underlying bonds threatened debt-funded buybacks and heavily leveraged corporate balance sheets.

  • GE's debt downgrade served as a warning event
  • The high-yield market reportedly shut for 41 days
  • Bond ETF collateral traded only intermittently
  • More than half of share buybacks were described as debt financed
  • Credit stress transmitted into equities by interrupting buybacks and funding

“it's not the stock market you have to be directly concerned with. It's keeping the bond market open.”

Danielle DiMartino Booth · 55:38

“the highyeld bond market shuts down. Goodbye, goodnight, Irene for forty one record days.”

Danielle DiMartino Booth · 56:17
#credit markets#high yield#jerome powell#share buybacks
Explainer1:15:59

How Compliance Costs Pushed Smaller Banks Toward Riskier Loans

DiMartino Booth says post-crisis compliance and capital requirements disproportionately burdened small and midsized banks. Unable to compete with the largest institutions, these lenders consolidated or moved further into commercial real estate, potentially concentrating a new source of balance-sheet risk.

  • Bank assets and lending became increasingly concentrated
  • Compliance costs have greater proportional impact on smaller banks
  • Smaller lenders moved further along the risk spectrum
  • Commercial real estate exposure rose on bank balance sheets
  • Later regulatory tiers arrived after many loans had already been made

“Small and mid sized banks in this country are not in good shape.”

Danielle DiMartino Booth · 1:16:17

“If you do, they're gonna go away out on the risk spectrum and make the crazy commercial real estate loans that they've got that they've…”

Danielle DiMartino Booth · 1:17:15
#regional banks#dodd-frank#commercial real estate#regulation

Story· 2

Story02:03

How a Wall Street Writer Became a Dallas Fed Insider

DiMartino Booth recounts an unconventional path through community college, finance, institutional trading, journalism, and finally the Dallas Fed. Her reporting on housing and systemic risk attracted Richard Fisher's attention and led to a role that evolved from speechwriting into market intelligence.

  • She began at community college after losing expected financial support
  • She earned graduate degrees in finance and journalism
  • Her housing-crisis reporting challenged conventional data sources
  • Richard Fisher recruited her to the Dallas Fed
  • Her role expanded as Fisher sought intelligence beyond the New York Fed desk

“And if you looked in the right place, there was an overwhelming amount of data, but if you looked in the usual place, everything was…”

Danielle DiMartino Booth · 12:19

“I came in as somebody to help with his speech writing.”

Danielle DiMartino Booth · 12:57
#career#journalism#wall street#dallas fed
Story26:27

The 1987 Moment That Taught Wall Street to Front-Run the Fed

DiMartino Booth traces modern expectations of central-bank market support to Alan Greenspan's response to the 1987 crash. She argues that advance signals from the New York markets desk taught traders to anticipate liquidity injections, creating a durable moral-hazard loop that later Fed leaders inherited.

  • Greenspan publicly promised support after the 1987 crash
  • Market desks allegedly warned bond dealers before liquidity injections
  • Traders learned to position ahead of Fed actions
  • Successive Fed chairs adopted similar market-sensitive philosophies

“They've been taught since the weeks and the months that followed that they can front run the fetist.”

Danielle DiMartino Booth · 29:17
#alan greenspan#moral hazard#fed put#1987 crash

Q&A· 1

Q&A36:40

Why America Cannot Copy Japan's Debt Experiment Exactly

The hosts debate whether reserve-currency status and a printing press allow the United States to issue debt without practical limits. DiMartino Booth says Japan has greater latitude because its sovereign debt is predominantly held domestically, while the United States remains more exposed to foreign buyers and confidence in the dollar.

  • Japan's government debt is largely held within Japan
  • US financing remains more dependent on foreign ownership
  • Reserve-currency status provides flexibility but is not unlimited
  • China has gradually shortened the maturity of its Treasury holdings

“We don't have the same latitude that Japan has because Japan's um sovereigns are mostly owned by the Japanese internally inside the country.”

Danielle DiMartino Booth · 37:37

“we do have reserve currency status, but we can't piss all over it”

Danielle DiMartino Booth · 38:11
#national debt#mmt#reserve currency#japan

Takeaway· 1

Takeaway1:29:33

Why She Recommends Engineering Before Finance, Law, or Medicine

Asked for career advice, DiMartino Booth recommends that high-school graduates build their undergraduate foundation in engineering before pursuing advanced study in another field. She sees engineering as a versatile analytical base with multiple disciplines and strong long-term career outcomes.

  • Start with an engineering bachelor's degree
  • Choose among the many engineering disciplines
  • Add finance, law, medicine, or another advanced field later
  • Engineering develops rigorous quantitative problem-solving skills

“I would tell them to go to college, fight the bullet and get an engineering degree.”

Danielle DiMartino Booth · 1:29:43

“After start with an engineering degree.”

Danielle DiMartino Booth · 1:30:17
#education#engineering#career advice