MMasters in Business
← All episodes
Henry Ward17 October 2025

Carta CEO Henry Ward on Private Credit & Private Markets

5Frameworks
10Insights

Listen

Frameworks in this episode

Insights & moments

The myth-busts, hot takes, explainers, and tools worth keeping.

Myth Buster· 2

Myth Buster26:58

Why Startup Success Cannot Be Reverse-Engineered from Winners

Ward and Ritholtz challenge the idea that visible entrepreneurial success proves a reproducible formula. Skill and hard work are necessary, but survivorship bias hides failed companies, while a sequence of favorable forks can dominate the eventual outcome.

  • Successful founders are an unrepresentative visible sample
  • Smart work and effort are table stakes rather than guarantees
  • Easy-looking outcomes conceal difficult and uncertain paths
  • Failure may contain cleaner signals than success
  • Advice from winners can mistake luck for a transferable cause

“I had to flip tails thirty two times in a row to get to where I am.”

Henry Ward · 27:53

“there's so much more signal in the failures than the wrong and the success is because success maybe it was skill, maybe was luck.”

Barry Ritholtz · 29:03
#entrepreneurship#luck#survivorship bias#failure
Myth Buster54:23

More Entrepreneurs Make Startup Success Harder, Not Easier

Ward argues that increasing participation raises the competitive standard for entrepreneurship. Because outcomes still contain substantial luck, founders need both exceptional skill and favorable circumstances; uncertainty does not make the field accessible to everyone.

  • More capable competitors raise the baseline skill requirement
  • Luck matters more when participants perform at similar levels
  • Startup uncertainty resembles acting more than measurable sprinting
  • High randomness does not eliminate the need for elite preparation
  • Ideas materially affect outcomes despite execution effort

“the more entrepreneurs there are, the harder entrepreneurship guts”

Henry Ward · 54:37

“You actually have to be a super skilled, you know, one hundred meters sprinter and you have to be lucky to do one of these…”

Henry Ward · 55:34
#entrepreneurship#competition#skill#luck

Hot Take· 2

Hot Take31:27

Why Software Companies Cannot Also Sell Customer Data

Ward argues that a software vendor's promise to safeguard customer information conflicts structurally with monetizing that information elsewhere. Selling data destroys the trust required to obtain it, which is why Carta possesses extensive private-market information but does not offer a monetized data product.

  • Software vendors receive data through a service relationship
  • Secondary data monetization contradicts confidentiality promises
  • Loss of trust can cannibalize the core software business
  • Carta sells workflow software rather than its customer data
  • Salesforce is presented as a major test case for the thesis

“software businesses cannot be data businesses.”

Henry Ward · 31:31

“We have tons of data, we do not have a monetizable data product.”

Henry Ward · 32:10
#data privacy#software#trust#business models
Hot Take38:05

Why a Venture-Stock Exchange May Never Work

After a decade working on private-market liquidity, Ward believes startup secondaries will not develop like public exchanges. Public and private markets reverse important pricing, block-size, and return-distribution dynamics, while private liquidity fragments into niches instead of concentrating at scale.

  • Private prices are set differently from public-market prices
  • Large private blocks can be easier to sell than single shares
  • Private returns follow power-law rather than normal distributions
  • Public-market portfolio math does not transfer cleanly
  • Private liquidity providers tend to fragment as they scale

“at least venture startup liquidity will never happen”

Henry Ward · 38:21

“In private markets, what's happened is there's equities and there's many others.”

Henry Ward · 40:06
#secondaries#liquidity#venture capital#market structure

Explainer· 3

Explainer11:51

How Carta Dematerialized Private Stock

Ward compares Carta's digitization of private equity records to the dematerialization of cash after the gold standard. Moving certificates, contracts, PDFs, and related records into the cloud made private ownership easier to update and move, but persuading lawyers and venture firms to abandon centuries-old paper practices was the hardest part.

  • Private equity records were fragmented across physical certificates and documents
  • Cloud records enabled equity information to move without moving physical inventory
  • Institutional resistance centered on established legal practices
  • Lawyers initially insisted that paper certificates were necessary

“We de materialized that. We put it all in the cloud.”

Henry Ward · 12:34

“Getting the ecosystem of venture capital to believe in the de materialization of private equity and private capital was the hardest part”

Henry Ward · 12:40
#private markets#digitization#equity#legaltech
Explainer34:10

Public Markets Are Shrinking While Private Growth Expands

Ward says private companies and private capital are expanding while the number of public companies declines, leaving ordinary investors with fewer public growth opportunities. Rather than forcing companies to list publicly, he advocates creating safe retail access to private capital.

  • The number of public companies has declined
  • Private-company formation is growing with private capital availability
  • Companies have fewer reasons to pursue public listings
  • Retail investors risk losing access to growth equity
  • Policy should focus on safe private-market access

“public markets is actually a shrinking industry.”

Henry Ward · 34:28

“I think the answer is to create safe access for everyday Americans into private capital.”

Henry Ward · 36:27
#private markets#retail investing#public markets#policy
Explainer47:32

The Missing Adviser for Employees Rich in Private Stock

Startup employees may earn ordinary cash salaries while holding private equity nominally worth millions, yet conventional advisers lack both the expertise and fee model to help them. Carta and Morgan Stanley are exploring financial advice for people who are high net worth on paper but cannot readily liquidate their assets.

  • Private-company employees can hold large illiquid positions
  • Traditional advisers specialize in liquid assets
  • Advisers cannot easily charge assets-under-management fees on private stock
  • Uncertainty makes employees prefer understandable cash compensation
  • A new advisory model could serve illiquid high-net-worth holders

“There is no equivalent in the private world.”

Henry Ward · 47:54

“we think it's worth solving wealth management for ill liquid holders.”

Henry Ward · 48:51
#employee equity#wealth management#illiquid assets#compensation

Story· 1

Story19:51

The Pricing Email That Carta Thought Might Destroy It

Carta's original per-certificate pricing generated volatile transactional revenue and could not support its expanding services. Ward personally told roughly two thousand customers that he had priced the product incorrectly and would move them to annual subscriptions; almost none left, and some said the correction reassured them that Carta would survive.

  • Transactional revenue was volatile and difficult to manage
  • Bundled services required recurring subscription economics
  • Ward admitted the pricing mistake directly to customers
  • Customers largely accepted the unilateral transition
  • Transparent vulnerability strengthened confidence in the business

“I made a mistake. I priced this wrong for you,”

Henry Ward · 21:02

“We lost almost no customers”

Henry Ward · 21:56
#pricing#subscriptions#saas#customer trust

Takeaway· 2

Takeaway29:12

Money Is a Fragile Motive for Founders

Ward argues that money fails as a durable entrepreneurial motive at both ends of the journey. Founders are often poor for years before success, and those who eventually become rich lose the very incentive that was supposed to keep them building; sustained founders instead love the activity itself.

  • Expected entrepreneurial earnings trail many conventional careers
  • Founders can remain poor through long seed and growth periods
  • Financial motivation weakens during prolonged uncertainty
  • Success also removes money as a reason to continue
  • Durable motivation comes from loving the game itself

“And the people that are successful over time in this business do it for the love of the game”

Henry Ward · 29:50

“you're poor, and you're it's you're living in constant uncertainty.”

Henry Ward · 30:34
#founder motivation#money#resilience#startups
Takeaway42:25

BlackRock's Bigger Opportunity: Expand the Entire Alternatives Market

Ward recounts BlackRock COO Rob Goldstein rejecting a narrow effort to capture competitors' share of a customer's alternatives-technology spending. The larger opportunity was to expand the customer's entire alternatives budget toward the scale of its public-market infrastructure budget, then capture part of the much larger market.

  • Public-market infrastructure spending greatly exceeds alternatives spending
  • Winning existing alternatives share leaves the market small
  • Market expansion can create more value than share capture
  • Large incumbents can benefit by building broader category infrastructure

“Well we need to do is figure out how to get that million dollars a year they spend an ALTS to be twenty five million…”

Henry Ward · 43:22

“we're trying to grow the market, not our percentage of the market”

Henry Ward · 43:36
#blackrock#alternatives#market growth#strategy