Why Someone Else's Mutual-Fund Exit Can Raise Your Tax Bill
A large mutual-fund redemption can force the fund to sell securities and realize gains. Those gains are distributed among the investors who remain, causing them to owe tax despite taking no action themselves; the ETF creation-redemption mechanism largely avoids this outcome.
- Large redemptions can force mutual funds to sell holdings
- Realized gains pass to investors who remain
- Investors may owe tax without selling their own shares
- ETFs generally isolate investors from other holders' redemptions
- Tax deferral is valuable even when lifetime tax is unchanged
“They end up paying taxes because you left, because you created a capital gain for everybody.”
“an ETF that simply doesn't happen. So it is a simply a fairer mechanism.”