Why Collars and Covered Calls Do Not Fix Concentrated-Stock Taxes
Options can reshape the risk around a concentrated holding, but they do not inherently remove its embedded tax liability. A collar limits a price range at a cost, while covered calls leave downside exposure and can force a taxable disposition if the shares are called away.
- Protective puts can soften a collapse but cost money.
- A collar does not erase capital gains.
- Covered calls retain downside risk.
- A rally can cause shares to be called away and trigger gains.
“It doesn't mean you're not gonna pay capital gains tax.”
“Either way, none of these solutions are optimal.”