MMasters in Business
← All episodes
Alan Krueger20 March 2019

Alan Krueger Remembered on Masters in Business (Podcast)

2Frameworks
13Insights

Listen

Frameworks in this episode

Insights & moments

The myth-busts, hot takes, explainers, and tools worth keeping.

Myth Buster· 2

Myth Buster13:53

The Border Study That Challenged Minimum-Wage Orthodoxy

Krueger recounts his study with David Card comparing fast-food employment in New Jersey and Pennsylvania after New Jersey increased its minimum wage. Contrary to their initial expectation, affected restaurants did not grow more slowly, helping redirect subsequent minimum-wage research.

  • The researchers expected slower restaurant growth
  • New Jersey restaurants grew at least as much as comparison restaurants
  • Within-state comparisons produced a similar result
  • Later studies using government records often reached the same conclusion

“and in fact we saw the opposite.”

Alan Krueger · 14:24

“I think that study was a turning point in research on the minimum wage.”

Alan Krueger · 14:49
#minimum wage#natural experiment#employment#research
Myth Buster31:45

Why Claims of Politically Manipulated Jobs Data Fail

Krueger responds to allegations that administrations manipulate employment statistics. He emphasizes the BLS's career workforce, its deliberate public process for methodological changes, and the normal noise that makes any single monthly release easy to misread.

  • Only the commissioner is a presidential appointee
  • Career economists and statisticians produce the data
  • Methodological changes are deliberate and disclosed
  • Monthly volatility should be interpreted within the longer trend

“No serious person doubts the credibility of the Bureau of Labor Statistics.”

Alan Krueger · 33:23

“the numbers may not be perfect”

Alan Krueger · 33:46
#bls#data integrity#misinformation#employment

Hot Take· 2

Hot Take16:29

Why Krueger Was Skeptical of Secular Stagnation

Krueger rejects the idea that the post-crisis United States was destined for decades of weak growth. He places greater weight on entrepreneurial ingenuity, new products, pent-up demand, and immigration as recurring sources of renewal.

  • Financial crises can leave lasting economic damage
  • Historical pessimism has repeatedly underestimated recovery
  • Entrepreneurial innovation can create new sources of growth
  • Immigration and pent-up demand can support expansion

“I'm skeptical of of that view.”

Alan Krueger · 16:47

“I put a lot of confidence in the ingenuity of American entrepreneurs.”

Alan Krueger · 17:01
#growth#innovation#secular stagnation#entrepreneurs
Hot Take40:22

How Premature Austerity Weakened the Recovery

Krueger criticizes sequestration and the withdrawal of fiscal support while the economy was still healing. He argues that cuts to research, infrastructure, education, and state and local employment reduced growth without addressing the long-run healthcare and entitlement costs driving deficits.

  • Sequestration cut discretionary spending arbitrarily
  • Public investment in research and infrastructure was reduced
  • State and local layoffs rose after Recovery Act support expired
  • Short-term austerity did not solve long-term entitlement pressures

“I think Congress made a major mistake with the sequester.”

Alan Krueger · 40:36

“We should be investing more in research and development, more in infrastructure, more in education”

Alan Krueger · 40:44
#austerity#fiscal policy#recovery#public investment

Explainer· 4

Explainer06:10

How the BLS Produces the Monthly Employment Picture

Krueger explains that the Bureau of Labor Statistics combines a household survey with an establishment survey covering nearly 400,000 workplaces. Its career staff repeatedly collect, clean, and release the data under institutional safeguards designed to preserve independence and credibility.

  • The household survey produces the unemployment rate
  • The establishment survey covers nearly 400,000 workplaces
  • Career civil servants perform almost all of the work
  • The administration receives results only shortly before public release

“The BLS is housed within the Labor Department, but it has a tremendous amount of independence.”

Alan Krueger · 06:10
#bls#employment#statistics#institutions
Explainer09:38

Why Major Employers Voluntarily Create Wage Floors

Walmart and McDonald's were raising wages as the labor market tightened. Krueger argues that these decisions reflect more than market clearing: morale, productivity, retention, and the social nature of employment can all make higher wages economically rational.

  • Tighter labor markets increase wage pressure
  • Companies can impose wage floors on themselves
  • Higher pay may improve morale and productivity
  • Higher wages may reduce employee turnover

“Sometimes the invisible hand needs a little bit of help.”

Alan Krueger · 09:44

“the labor market is a social entity and worker morale is important.”

Alan Krueger · 10:15
#wages#productivity#retention#labor
Explainer20:39

What Really Drove Falling Labor-Force Participation

Krueger attributes much of the participation decline to an aging workforce, the earlier peak in women's participation, and the eventual exit of some long-term unemployed people. He cautions that a short stabilization in the series may be noise rather than a durable reversal.

  • Baby-boomer retirement mechanically lowers participation
  • Women's participation peaked around 2000
  • Long-term unemployment can lead people to leave the labor force
  • Short-term stabilization should not automatically be called a reversal

“Slack means that we're not using all the resources that we can be using.”

Alan Krueger · 20:48

“I think at best we could say labor for its participation is stabilized.”

Alan Krueger · 23:23
#demographics#participation#retirement#labor
Explainer23:48

The Middle-Class Squeeze Is Bigger Than the Top One Percent

Krueger argues that a shrinking middle class weakens aggregate demand and erodes shared economic interests. He also shows that the widening income gap between college- and high-school-headed households exceeded the estimated average effect of redistributing the top one percent's increased income share.

  • Middle-income households spend a larger share of their earnings
  • A broad middle class supports economic and social cohesion
  • Inherited wealth is becoming more important at the very top
  • Education and specific skills explain substantial inequality below the top one percent

“The middle class has been under a lot of pressure, and we've seen the middle class shrink.”

Alan Krueger · 24:16

“it's not only the top one percent that's causing the shifts and inequality”

Alan Krueger · 26:00
#inequality#middle class#education#skills

Story· 1

Story47:06

The Auto Bailout Worked Better Than Expected

Krueger describes the post-bailout recovery of US automakers as stronger than policymakers expected in 2009. Restructuring addressed long-running operational problems while pent-up demand, easier credit, and improved products helped revive sales.

  • Automakers faced structural problems predating the crisis
  • Restructuring changed GM and Chrysler materially
  • Vehicle quality improved after the bailout
  • The recovery exceeded policymakers' original expectations

“it has been far more successful than we expected in two thousand nine.”

Alan Krueger · 48:50
#auto bailout#restructuring#manufacturing#recovery

Q&A· 1

Q&A53:05

Why Nationalizing Major Banks Could Have Deepened the Panic

The host proposes putting major insolvent banks into receivership, wiping out shareholders, imposing creditor losses, and later returning cleaned institutions to private ownership. Krueger argues that the scale, recapitalization cost, lengthy resolution process, and risk of runs on other banks made that path more dangerous than it appeared.

  • Resolving systemically important banks could take many years
  • Government recapitalization would expose taxpayers to large losses
  • Wiping out one bank's shareholders could trigger selling elsewhere
  • The crisis required choosing among risky options, not between safe and risky ones

“we were staring into the abyss.”

Alan Krueger · 56:23

“It was the least bad solution”

Alan Krueger · 1:00:20
#banking crisis#receivership#tarp#systemic risk

Takeaway· 3

Takeaway1:00:49

Krueger's Two Major Criticisms of the Federal Reserve

Krueger faults the Fed for failing to tighten mortgage-lending standards before the crisis and for ending quantitative easing too abruptly during the recovery. He rejects the belief that banks could adequately regulate themselves and favors more continuous monetary support once the crisis began.

  • The Fed had authority to strengthen lending standards
  • Low or zero down payments amplified default incentives
  • Private-sector housing optimism was another contributing cause
  • Ending quantitative easing too early created stop-start policy

“I do hold the FED responsible UH for a very core component of the crisis.”

Alan Krueger · 1:02:17

“I think they took the photo off the gas a little bit too soon”

Alan Krueger · 1:02:54
#federal reserve#mortgages#quantitative easing#financial crisis
Takeaway1:04:14

Businesses Must Redesign Work for an Aging Population

Krueger identifies slower growth in the working-age population, lower immigration, and declining participation as major forces shaping business. Employers may need more flexible work arrangements to attract workers who would otherwise remain outside the labor force.

  • Working-age population growth is slowing
  • Lower immigration constrains labor supply
  • Population aging changes workforce needs
  • Flexible work can attract additional workers

“demographic shifts are having a tremendous effect on the US.”

Alan Krueger · 1:04:21

“How can they make work more flexible so they can attract more workers?”

Alan Krueger · 1:05:01
#demographics#immigration#flexible work#workforce
Takeaway1:05:20

Economics Needs More History and More Intellectual Diversity

Krueger says economists cling too tightly to established views and update too slowly when evidence changes. He calls for a broader discipline in which economic history becomes part of core training, especially because modern financial crises often repeat patterns visible in earlier panics and crashes.

  • Economists can be slow to change their minds
  • The profession lacks sufficient diversity of views
  • Graduate training underemphasizes economic history
  • Past crises provide useful models for interpreting new ones

“people are slow to update, to change their mind in spite of evidence.”

Alan Krueger · 1:05:47

“I'd like to see economic history become a part of the core and economics.”

Alan Krueger · 1:06:26
#economics#economic history#evidence#education